Live data from Hacker News

Newton, the Man (1946)

www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk

1–10 of 21 posts

Re: Newton, the Man (1946)

#3
Hagiography aside, Newton, the Man was also mean-spirited and would go to great lengths to ensure his "opponents" would suffer. I remember reading that as President of the Royal Society, he politicized the Leibniz Calculus issue so much that even our politicians can pick up a lesson or two :-) [1]

Why am I telling this? Well, I'd like people to realize that our heroes also have flaws and we don't fall to blind hero-worship. There are, after all, lessons to be learnt on how not to be as well :-)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leibniz%E2%80%93Newton_calculu...

Re: Newton, the Man (1946)

#5
post #3

Hagiography aside, Newton, the Man was also mean-spirited and would go to great lengths to ensure his "opponents" would suffer. I remember reading that as President of the Royal Society, he politicized the Leibniz Calculus issue so much that even our politicians can pick up a lesson or two :-) [1] Why am I telling this? Well, I'd like people to realize that our heroes also have flaws and we don't fall to blind hero-w…

That might be why when he worked at the Mint he tool the task of finding and prosecuting "coiners" so seriously - even working undercover himself to gather information and running the prosecutions himself:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newton#Later_life

World's greatest scientist turned undercover crime fighting superhero!

Re: Newton, the Man (1946)

#6
post #3

Hagiography aside, Newton, the Man was also mean-spirited and would go to great lengths to ensure his "opponents" would suffer. I remember reading that as President of the Royal Society, he politicized the Leibniz Calculus issue so much that even our politicians can pick up a lesson or two :-) [1] Why am I telling this? Well, I'd like people to realize that our heroes also have flaws and we don't fall to blind hero-w…

I don't think that page on Wikipedia can be the source of your information—it says nothing to support the claim of mean-spiritedness.

Re: Newton, the Man (1946)

#7
post #6
post #3

Hagiography aside, Newton, the Man was also mean-spirited and would go to great lengths to ensure his "opponents" would suffer. I remember reading that as President of the Royal Society, he politicized the Leibniz Calculus issue so much that even our politicians can pick up a lesson or two :-) [1] Why am I telling this? Well, I'd like people to realize that our heroes also have flaws and we don't fall to blind hero-w…

I don't think that page on Wikipedia can be the source of your information—it says nothing to support the claim of mean-spiritedness.

You're right.Here's a better source. I have highlighted the relevant passage on my Kindle from the book "A Brief History of Time" and sharing as an image because I can't quite get to post directly as text.

https://imgur.com/3hJ9z6O

Re: Newton, the Man (1946)

#8
post #3

Hagiography aside, Newton, the Man was also mean-spirited and would go to great lengths to ensure his "opponents" would suffer. I remember reading that as President of the Royal Society, he politicized the Leibniz Calculus issue so much that even our politicians can pick up a lesson or two :-) [1] Why am I telling this? Well, I'd like people to realize that our heroes also have flaws and we don't fall to blind hero-w…

Is there strong evidence that people don't understand this already? There are plenty of lists such as this one pointing out similar people who were immensely talented in some respect.

https://www.toptenz.net/top-10-geniuses-shockingly-horrible-...

Re: Newton, the Man (1946)

#9
post #3

Hagiography aside, Newton, the Man was also mean-spirited and would go to great lengths to ensure his "opponents" would suffer. I remember reading that as President of the Royal Society, he politicized the Leibniz Calculus issue so much that even our politicians can pick up a lesson or two :-) [1] Why am I telling this? Well, I'd like people to realize that our heroes also have flaws and we don't fall to blind hero-w…

He also was pretty nasty to Robert Hooke (of Hooke's Law and microscopy fame). Yes, he was probably a better scientist than Hooke, but Hooke wasn't nothing either.

Re: Newton, the Man (1946)

#10
post #9
post #3

Hagiography aside, Newton, the Man was also mean-spirited and would go to great lengths to ensure his "opponents" would suffer. I remember reading that as President of the Royal Society, he politicized the Leibniz Calculus issue so much that even our politicians can pick up a lesson or two :-) [1] Why am I telling this? Well, I'd like people to realize that our heroes also have flaws and we don't fall to blind hero-w…

He also was pretty nasty to Robert Hooke (of Hooke's Law and microscopy fame). Yes, he was probably a better scientist than Hooke, but Hooke wasn't nothing either.

The famous "shoulders of giants" quote has been seen by some as a mean dig at the hunchbacked Hooke.
Post reply on HN