Live data from Hacker News

Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

bradleytaunt.com

11–20 of 215 posts

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#11
Can anyone remember if the old AOL landing page linked to AOL created content or content by 3rd parties?

I’ve made the argument before that Google is the new AOL homepage. It’s the gateway to the web for a huge majority as AOL was at one time. AMP is concentrating Google’s web just as AOL once did for first timers.

Google has much more utility but it’s still very similar. AOL had email, web, chat, news, shopping? (maybe late days of AOL), and let’s not forget search.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#13
post #3

yeah but then how do you get organic traffic?

On a related note, what does organic search traffic look like these days? I was once personally invested in running several small content sites and at the time organic traffic was pretty much entirely from Google. There were other inbound sources - Bing, Yahoo!, etc. - but they were so negligible that it would have been reasonable to ignore them completely for the purposes of optimization.

I've been using DDG as my primary search engine now for several years, and using Google no longer "feels like the Web" for me. I imagine I have one hell of a case of observation bias in that, but it does seem like alternatives have been gaining some traction in recent years.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#14
post #4

Just to be clear, there is a mistake in this post. Adding a noindex tag will cause google to not display the page in their search results. They will still crawl ( they have to), in order to see that directive. Also, keep in mind that google has recently changed the way they deal with robots.txt. So they only way to do what the author is suggesting is to add the noindex meta tag and let them crawl. Once they are remov…

How do you block their IP? Google has hundreds of numbers and AFAIK they don’t even publish all of them.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#15
post #4

Just to be clear, there is a mistake in this post. Adding a noindex tag will cause google to not display the page in their search results. They will still crawl ( they have to), in order to see that directive. Also, keep in mind that google has recently changed the way they deal with robots.txt. So they only way to do what the author is suggesting is to add the noindex meta tag and let them crawl. Once they are remov…

How do you block their IP? Google has hundreds of numbers and AFAIK they don’t even publish all of them.

You can block Googlebot by User-Agent and IP addresses.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#16
post #4

Just to be clear, there is a mistake in this post. Adding a noindex tag will cause google to not display the page in their search results. They will still crawl ( they have to), in order to see that directive. Also, keep in mind that google has recently changed the way they deal with robots.txt. So they only way to do what the author is suggesting is to add the noindex meta tag and let them crawl. Once they are remov…

I've found that google will still include the page in their search index if it's been discovered by means other than crawling the resource itself (e.g. it's linked from other pages). The search result will simply not include any content from the page, since they've presumably not crawled the page.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#20
post #4

Just to be clear, there is a mistake in this post. Adding a noindex tag will cause google to not display the page in their search results. They will still crawl ( they have to), in order to see that directive. Also, keep in mind that google has recently changed the way they deal with robots.txt. So they only way to do what the author is suggesting is to add the noindex meta tag and let them crawl. Once they are remov…

How do you block their IP? Google has hundreds of numbers and AFAIK they don’t even publish all of them.

There are services that track google IPs, those doing black hat SEO and cloaking rely on them.

Google is going to crawl, you just can’t stop them from crawling even if you tell them not to in robots.txt. Best option at this point is to add a noindex tag on pages and let them crawl to see it.

Post reply on HN