Live data from Hacker News

Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

bradleytaunt.com

1–10 of 215 posts

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#4
Just to be clear, there is a mistake in this post. Adding a noindex tag will cause google to not display the page in their search results. They will still crawl ( they have to), in order to see that directive.

Also, keep in mind that google has recently changed the way they deal with robots.txt. So they only way to do what the author is suggesting is to add the noindex meta tag and let them crawl. Once they are removed from the index, block the google IPs.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#5
"I don't like one of their products so I don't want anyone to find the stuff I write online"

Unless you are dependent on SEM, AMP doesn't really hurt you. This whole no-index thing is ridiculous and not at all possible for any sufficiently large website/company.

Only thing I can agree with is the alternative search engine point. We really need more competition in the field, so Google is forced to cater to it's user's wishes more instead of purely pushing their agenda on them.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#7
> As fewer results of such not-for-profit websites show up in Google Search, competition will be reintroduced to the search market.

I don't think it will. While I personally hate AMP, and disagree with many of Google's practices, this is not the solution. Google is everywhere.

It is the default search engine on almost every browser, as well as on most devices. How often do you hear someone say "look it up" as opposed to "Google it"? The latter is much more common in my experience. Google is synonymous with internet searches.

Outside of tech circles, no one is going to make an effort to even try other search engines. There's a reason Bing and Yahoo are treated as a joke.

Google is also the best at searches. While other search engines are slowly catching up, and Google's own results are becoming worse, it's still way better then most search engines - especially when it comes to specific and local/regional results.

Lastly, blocking Google means that you site also won't show up on Startpage.com results, because it sources results from Google. This is unfortunate, since Startpage is definitely one of the search engines that respect your privacy the most.

Re: Dear Google, I'm Blocking You from My Website

#8
> Google needs to stick to being a solid search engine instead of trying to be gate keepers

While I agree with the sentiment, I feel like this ship sailed years ago - it's like saying "Amazon should stick to being an ecommerce platform".

What's more, Google was never in the business of "being a solid search engine". Google is and always has been in the business of selling access to users' eyeballs. AMP - as much as I hate it - is directly in line with their core business.

Post reply on HN