Live data from Hacker News

Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

petapixel.com

101–110 of 219 posts

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#101

This is a seriously awesome piece of work. The mathematics in the paper are pretty dense but if you're ok with vector calculus its not too bad. The implication here is that you can build lenses that have a consistent focal plane across their entire surface. A pair of glasses made this way would have crystal clear vision regardless of your 'look' direction (as an example). It also suggests that you could build lenses…

[deleted]

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#102
post #94

There are various people speculating on the economic significance of this solution, which, to me, is rather missing the point. It's like measuring the significance of the excavation of Tutankhamen's† tomb by the tourist revenues of museums. The point of economics is that it keeps us alive so we can do math and also think in other ways; the point of consciousness is not to make money. I don't think there is any econom…

> The point of economics is that it keeps us alive so we can do math

The most hacker news comment I read all year

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#103
post #102
post #94

There are various people speculating on the economic significance of this solution, which, to me, is rather missing the point. It's like measuring the significance of the excavation of Tutankhamen's† tomb by the tourist revenues of museums. The point of economics is that it keeps us alive so we can do math and also think in other ways; the point of consciousness is not to make money. I don't think there is any econom…

> The point of economics is that it keeps us alive so we can do math The most hacker news comment I read all year

I notice you don't seem to have dared to say you disagree — would you say that the point of consciousness is to make money?

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#104

It's an interesting mathematical result, but note that gives a solution for the problem of the spherical aberration, but real lens have also chromatic aberration. I.E. the speed of light for each color inside the glass is slightly different, so the value n (refraction index) in the equation is different, so in the equation you get a different surface for each color. In the real lens you must pick one surface, so the…

wouldn’t this be simply stacking SA free lenses, with the remaining aberrations being alignment related?

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#105
post #103
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The point of economics is that it keeps us alive so we can do math The most hacker news comment I read all year

I notice you don't seem to have dared to say you disagree — would you say that the point of consciousness is to make money?

[deleted]

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#106
post #92
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hazelnut spread is one of those things that is much more commonly referred to as the brand name. No one says "Reynolds wrap" they say "aluminum foil". No one says "hazelnut spread", they say Nutella. No one says "resealable sandwich bags", they say ziploc bags.

Nutella though is a sugar-and-palm/vegetable-oil spread, which - probably accidentally - contains traces of hazelnuts, powdered milk and cocoa.

I don't understand the downvoting of the parent here, which is factually correct and worth noting. It's incredibly unhealthy and this is just down to marketing that anybody eats it. You can make really nice chocolate spreads with your own hazelnuts

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#107
post #92
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hazelnut spread is one of those things that is much more commonly referred to as the brand name. No one says "Reynolds wrap" they say "aluminum foil". No one says "hazelnut spread", they say Nutella. No one says "resealable sandwich bags", they say ziploc bags.

Nutella though is a sugar-and-palm/vegetable-oil spread, which - probably accidentally - contains traces of hazelnuts, powdered milk and cocoa.

[deleted]

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#108
post #103
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The point of economics is that it keeps us alive so we can do math The most hacker news comment I read all year

I notice you don't seem to have dared to say you disagree — would you say that the point of consciousness is to make money?

No. But there are things besides money and math. Like photography!

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#109
post #103
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The point of economics is that it keeps us alive so we can do math The most hacker news comment I read all year

I notice you don't seem to have dared to say you disagree — would you say that the point of consciousness is to make money?

There's more to life than either math or money, haha. I think a lot of people might fit something in there about friends, family, or community. Spiritual growth maybe?

There's options.

Re: Goodbye Aberration: Physicist Solves 2,000-Year-Old Optical Problem

#110
post #103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I notice you don't seem to have dared to say you disagree — would you say that the point of consciousness is to make money?

There's more to life than either math or money, haha. I think a lot of people might fit something in there about friends, family, or community. Spiritual growth maybe? There's options.

I venture to say that spiritual growth is part of consciousness — that is, it's "math and thinking in other ways", which is of course what I said above, not "math".

As for friends, family, and community, what is it that gives friendship value, if not your conscious experience of the friendship, and your friend's? Could you coherently call something a good friendship if neither friend enjoys it or improves their thinking from it? The same questions generalize to family and community, though in more complex ways.

Post reply on HN