Live data from Hacker News

YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

boingboing.net

71–80 of 449 posts

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#71
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All those things are overrated, putting up some videos on YouTube is no guarantee of an audience. You still have promotional work to do. And it’s not nearly as expensive to host videos now compared to the past.

I’ve been very happy with Cloudflare Stream lately. We stream ~2-3k mins/day and have never had a complaint.

Unfortunately Cloudflare has a history of censoring content as well though.

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#72

What's next, cracking and reverse-engineering? Debugging? (Anti-authoritarian) programming ? As usual, Stallman tends to be quite prescient: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html (perhaps more like "right to watch" in this context.)

youtube is not the internet, it's a privately run silo. I think it's actually better if people stop using it for everything. We've somehow got to the point where we are demanding private companies somehow preserve our freedoms simply because we've entrenched ourselves in their commercial products and given them control over content. Let youtube curate their content, I wish they'd do it more. Then maybe we will start seeing some more diversity rather than these massive silos

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#73
post #48

It's like banning Karate & Judo because it teaches violence. (When it actually improves personal security/safety)

Won’t be long until gunsmithing videos about how to manufacture machine guns (legal in most countries with the right license) are banned, too. EDIT: Spoke too soon. It’s already gone. https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2019/01/04/coat-hanger-m... What’s next? Lockpicking?

Bookburnings of the anarchist cookbook, obviously...

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#74

Every news about authoritarian overreach prompts some discussion about the need for decentralization. Yet, decentralization of services is moot if the underlying physical connectivity layer can still be controlled/filtered from a single point. Then there's the matter of discovering decentralized/distributed services. We have literally billions of devices capable of sending and receiving signals, including millions of…

tor is one answer. of course that could be blocked but there are ways of hiding its use in general.

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I always think he’s mostly right, but a little too uncompromising, but then everything he says comes true. I don’t know how he predicted so far ahead at the time, it’s humbling. As a software author working at startups, am I part of the problem? I don’t understand how to make a good living without locking down the code to some extent, with few exceptions (it’s hard to found red hat)

Honestly? Take the mentality you see in the world - the bottom line comes first, the consumer wants easy consumption, security comes first, whatever else - and try to imagine where that comes in conflict with the things you love. What would have caused that conflict? What, if anything, do you see coming out of it? And if you think Stallman was the tinfoil-hat prophet, you gotta hear about this guy Karl Marx. He predi…

> ... security comes first, whatever else...

Really? the feeling of being secure may come first. Think of how much modems/routers/phones or any other embedded device comes with obsolete software pieces with lots of security bugs. The non-free methodology of software development, I feel, is actually killing security, and making everybody more vulnerable.

Most firms don't like giving the source code of the devices away. I understand that they have their own reasons for that (whether it is right is another thing). But at least, there should be an official way to unlock those devices and run custom software pieces (which of course, voids warranty).

These days more people are moving to "Open Source," but not "Free Software." See how Linux & busybox essentially making any hardware non-free. Hope people understand the difference and help make the world better.

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#76
I've noticed quite a few free software enthusiast posting their content to LBRY[1]. Doesn't seem like a perfect solution for every type of video getting messed up by YouTube lately, but I think infosec could find a good home there.

[1] https://lbry.com/what

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#78

What's next, cracking and reverse-engineering? Debugging? (Anti-authoritarian) programming ? As usual, Stallman tends to be quite prescient: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html (perhaps more like "right to watch" in this context.)

I always think he’s mostly right, but a little too uncompromising, but then everything he says comes true. I don’t know how he predicted so far ahead at the time, it’s humbling. As a software author working at startups, am I part of the problem? I don’t understand how to make a good living without locking down the code to some extent, with few exceptions (it’s hard to found red hat)

He is always right because his predictions about companies are as cynical as possible. He assumes every company acts entirely in its own interests and will do whatever they can get away with to make the most profit.

And of course this ends up being true almost every time.

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#79
post #64

I wonder if this will give a boost to a new Peertube instance dedicated to infosec content. Seems like this should be right up infosec's people alley. Peertube uses web torrenting to distribute videos, so it should be possible to host it without needing the massive delivery infrastructure of Youtube.

I'll gladly peer my instance to it if one comes up. I wish this had a !RemindMe

Re: YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube

#80
It's inevitable. In Fahrenheit 451, books start getting banned because every person who ever gets offended starts asking for the thing that offended them to go away and people comply.

This is what happens to big targets. It's why it's important to preserve the independent host.

Post reply on HN