Live data from Hacker News

Google CTF 2019

capturetheflag.withgoogle.com

51–60 of 140 posts

Re: Google CTF 2019

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This aspect could be the real hurdle: "Pay a fee of up to 10% of the sweepstakes' value, depending on who is allowed to enter." So they would need to pay Quebec $3K just to have the competition available there, even if it is a global competition. It sounds to me that Quebec have got to have some reason for these Quebec special laws. It has nothing to do with France, there has to be another reason. Does anyone have an…

Almost everything in Canada, every ad, promotion, service has some kind of special section for Quebec. They insist on having completely different laws for every little thing. From a companies POV, its probably as legally onerous as operating in a different country altogether - not worth it.

> From a companies POV, its probably as legally onerous as operating in a different country altogether - not worth it

It's much worse than that. Google didn't research the sweepstakes laws in, say, Paraguay or the Gambia before making this announcement. They figure that, in the worst case, their legal department will tell them not to award the prize if the winner comes from a country where they can't legally award it, and they'll scramble the necessary PR people if that comes to pass.

For Quebec, on the other hand, they'll be forbidden from carrying on business in all of Canada if they advertise this competition as one that can be won in Quebec. A terrible chilling effect - and I say this as someone who universally favours the freedom and self-determination of small nations such as Quebec.

Re: Google CTF 2019

#52
I’m always amazed how a company that creates the world’s most popular mobile OS and web browser is unable to code a decent mobile webpage.

Scrolling this page is sufferable, anchor links don’t work well, etc. Basic stuff.

Look no further than G Suite, Google Cloud for more examples.

Re: Google CTF 2019

#53
post #31

Does someone do in-depth posts/videos/talks about any of these (Google or FB) CTF challenges by breaking up what is happening, what, why and how they tried per challenege and how did they finally come to the solution step-by-step? These things have always intimidated me and I'd love to know more.

I started streaming it yesterday on my Twitch channel, but I was asked not to by a Google employee.

I've been working through the Beginner's Quest instead, which is actually a lot of fun and has a cute story.

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/442406188 if anyone wants to see the broadcast from yesterday.

Re: Google CTF 2019

#55

I’m always amazed how a company that creates the world’s most popular mobile OS and web browser is unable to code a decent mobile webpage. Scrolling this page is sufferable, anchor links don’t work well, etc. Basic stuff. Look no further than G Suite, Google Cloud for more examples.

[deleted]

Re: Google CTF 2019

#56

I’m always amazed how a company that creates the world’s most popular mobile OS and web browser is unable to code a decent mobile webpage. Scrolling this page is sufferable, anchor links don’t work well, etc. Basic stuff. Look no further than G Suite, Google Cloud for more examples.

I have heard of this argument often, and I don't quite understand it. It's similar to saying "I'm always amazed at how a country that has the most number of Nobel prize winners has some citizens that can't do calculus"

The people that work on Android and Chrome are not the people who work on websites. It's okay to say the website doesn't meet your expectations, but it's better to recognize that those are different projects worked on by different people with different set of requirements and resources.

Re: Google CTF 2019

#57
post #31

Does someone do in-depth posts/videos/talks about any of these (Google or FB) CTF challenges by breaking up what is happening, what, why and how they tried per challenege and how did they finally come to the solution step-by-step? These things have always intimidated me and I'd love to know more.

Check out LiveOverflow on YouTube. He's gone in depth on a bunch of CTF tasks and his solving process.

Re: Google CTF 2019

#58
post #31

Does someone do in-depth posts/videos/talks about any of these (Google or FB) CTF challenges by breaking up what is happening, what, why and how they tried per challenege and how did they finally come to the solution step-by-step? These things have always intimidated me and I'd love to know more.

People often write this up after the fact.

Google’s CTF normally drops write ups (both their own and links to external solvers’) in some shared repository afterwards.

Of course they won’t go play by play through everything they thought about every time, but they are pretty good reads.

Re: Google CTF 2019

#59
post #48

Dig at Apple from the third stage of the beginners' quest; "Your first thought is "Why does the display stand need to announce its price? And exactly how much does 999 dollars convert to in Xenonivian Bucklets?"

Stuck on this one, can see readme.flag but not sure how to proceed

Re: Google CTF 2019

#60

I’m always amazed how a company that creates the world’s most popular mobile OS and web browser is unable to code a decent mobile webpage. Scrolling this page is sufferable, anchor links don’t work well, etc. Basic stuff. Look no further than G Suite, Google Cloud for more examples.

To be fair, the challenges are impossible to solve on a mobile phone so I am not sure why they should invest time and effort to make it mobile friendly.
Post reply on HN