Live data from Hacker News

Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

wsj.com

61–70 of 277 posts

Re: Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

#61
I've met a hell of a lot of authoritarians in the crypto scene over the past decade. Blockchain technology is a centralized datastore so of course it's a tool for global authoritarianism; think IBM in the 1930s selling slow databases to the Nazi's so they can keep a universal ledger of the Jews.

P2P distributed architectures such as Holochain which actually decentralize data and control are far more positive paradigms for humanity.

Re: Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

#62
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would anyone want a facebook coin that is completely controlled by Facebook which can be controlled by the government when with Bitcoin you get complete sovereignty?

Because not everyone cares about "complete sovereignty"? There's a reason why all these companies are still successful, most people don't care that much about their privacy or other dignities if it means convenience.

Then I see no difference from USD. What exactly is the point? Yet another payment method?

Re: Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

#64
What I find hilarious is that Zuckerberg has probably been trolling the forums of bitcoin.org and reddit crypto groups for many months.

And like any good crypto "expert", he spent his time sharing opinions and copying other peoples source code versus building anything real.

Re: Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

#66
post #31

Ugh. This will pass too. The value of Bitcoin is in the fact that nobody can control and censor it. It's black market money. If it didn't have this quality, it'd be useless. Nobody (meaning customers) cares about Facebook launching a coin. Facebook will not be the champion of freedom. How do I know? Ask yourself, if Facebook Coin is going to be available in Crimea (currently under sanctions) or Iran (currently under…

You're forgetting how much credit card transaction suck. As I see it this is the main problem facebook could solve through sheer volume of use: microtransactions. Granted this is about the worst way this future could come about....

If Libra is a threat to credit cards, then why are Visa and MasterCard investing at least $10M each in it?

Re: Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

#67

If Facebook can pull this off they will have brought about the first universal internet currency, which would be a stunning achievement and could revolutionalize the web as we know it. Failed projects give us some idea of what their challenges will be. Cryptocurrencies right now have a trade off between scalability and decentralization. Bitcoin is theoretically decentralized even though the reality is more complex. B…

The choice of consensus algorithm (PoW/PoS) has nothing to do with scalability (tx/s)

Re: Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

#68
Why does this centralized stablecoin need to be crypto? It's not like they need to raise funding for this.

They could have made their own boring but extremely well positioned WePay / Paypal alternative ages ago, and instead they waited until cryptocurrencies are past peak hype to launch this. Puzzling.

I guess the only thing they have to sell here is the privacy aspect of crypto, but I doubt you'll get effective privacy from Facebook on any Facebook platform, crypto or not.

Re: Facebook’s New Cryptocurrency Gets Big Backers

#70
post #31

Ugh. This will pass too. The value of Bitcoin is in the fact that nobody can control and censor it. It's black market money. If it didn't have this quality, it'd be useless. Nobody (meaning customers) cares about Facebook launching a coin. Facebook will not be the champion of freedom. How do I know? Ask yourself, if Facebook Coin is going to be available in Crimea (currently under sanctions) or Iran (currently under…

I'm just going to add to this: it's been 10 years. Hacker News is still hoping very hard this so called libertarian wet dream cryptocurrency called Bitcoin will soon be out of the picture, replaced by something proper, that is fair and doesn't make you feel angry. And yet, it's still here, angering a whole bunch of people who didn't buy early and think the distribution is unfair & the political ideas behind it are awful and yet, Bitcoin is still #1 and widely used. "Blockchain not Bitcoin" hype is gone (remember how big banks invested millions blockchain projects?). Ethereum scammy ICOs hype is gone. This big-corp-coin thing will soon be gone too.

And all the issues people talk about here - like solving micropayments - are already being successfully solved by Lightning Network. Quietly.

Post reply on HN