Live data from Hacker News

Is science fiction dying?

mobile.salon.com

11–20 of 56 posts

Re: Is science fiction dying?

#11
SciFi might not be dying, but reading that prose nearly killed me. Anyway...

Does the genre continue to have new and useful things to say? I still remember when I first came across the idea of recreational engineered viruses as a substitute for drugs (I think it was in a Richard Morgan book?). I think SciFi is becoming more original, not less.

Re: Is science fiction dying?

#15
post #9
post #2

Giant wall of text, so I skimmed, but I think, no. Art never dies, it just finds a niche when the general public finds a new fad. Commercially, sci-fi seems to be doing well. Moon, District 9, Avatar, Star Trek. As a forecast of tech-to-come, who can say if it's as accurate as it once was, we'll have to wait for the future to arrive to really know, right? Aside from an enjoyable read, sci-fi is still inspiring people…

For due diligence: "Where is my flying car?" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMPH0tlC5K4 Sci-fi generally fails at future predictions.

Google maps, cellphones, talking computers, speech recognition, robots, autonomous vehicles, nuclear weapons, space travel, alternative biochemistry, touch screens, GPS, handheld translators, etc.

Yup. Sci-fi generally fails at predicting future tech.

Re: Is science fiction dying?

#17
Science fiction is fine it's just going through a bit of a lull at the moment. The current big market is contemporary fantasy aimed at a female readership, and that's where publishers are putting their money, which means there is less to spend on other similar (and I use the word loosely) genres. They are simply going after what sells to the widest audience.

I think sci-fi is also suffering from the decline in interest of the sciences in general. It's a shame but that's the way it is.

Quality rises to the top eventually, it will return.

Re: Is science fiction dying?

#18
Skim the article and jump to comments to find that everyone else has done the same. How delightful. Shame the article didn't match the title. Doesn't appear that there is any reason to suggest sci-fi is dying.

Re: Is science fiction dying?

#19
I am a hardcore sci-fi fan. Although I basically grew up in a library, the most fascinating part of it were the two or three racks nobody frequented than me: the racks were full of hardcore sci-fi like heinlein, asimov, pkdick, silverberg, leguin, pohl, you name them. In that sense, Sci-Fi is actually dying, because in the last 10 years, I hardly found something that even remotely compares with the great work of these guys except for the works of one author, Iain. M. Banks.

Re: Is science fiction dying?

#20
post #9
post #2

Giant wall of text, so I skimmed, but I think, no. Art never dies, it just finds a niche when the general public finds a new fad. Commercially, sci-fi seems to be doing well. Moon, District 9, Avatar, Star Trek. As a forecast of tech-to-come, who can say if it's as accurate as it once was, we'll have to wait for the future to arrive to really know, right? Aside from an enjoyable read, sci-fi is still inspiring people…

For due diligence: "Where is my flying car?" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMPH0tlC5K4 Sci-fi generally fails at future predictions.

You don't really read sci-fi for predictions though?
Post reply on HN