Live data from Hacker News

Was Alonzo Church Taoist?

lambdaway.free.fr

1–10 of 24 posts

Re: Was Alonzo Church Taoist?

#7
I don't see any connection between this article and Taoism at all, apart from a quote at the top and a sentence at the bottom, both of which seem unconnected to the rest of the article. What am I missing?

Re: Was Alonzo Church Taoist?

#8
I’m disappointed; this is as shallow an understanding of Taoism as you’re likely to get. Sure, there is a core religious concept called “Taoism” that can sort of be described as “everything is a zero-sum duality of a producer and a consumer, which returns to nothing in equilibrium”—but in practice, people who are Taoist have a whole bunch of other, much more interesting beliefs.

There’s an instant-classic article waiting to be written, about the usefulness of Taoism (and intertwined concepts like qigong and neidan) as a thought-paradigm for pursuing mastery in modern intellectual crafts like computer programming. (It’s a shame that Robert C. Martin isn’t versed with Taoism; he keeps rubbing up against these ideas tangentially but never colliding with them.)

There’s also a less classic, but highly entertaining article waiting to be written, comparing-and-contrasting computer programming to Taoist martial arts as practiced in Xianxia novels. Abelson and Sussman’s “programmer as wizard” analogy was close, but there’s an even better one.

Re: Was Alonzo Church Taoist?

#9
post #7

I don't see any connection between this article and Taoism at all, apart from a quote at the top and a sentence at the bottom, both of which seem unconnected to the rest of the article. What am I missing?

I think they’re just talking about the I Ching specifically, not really Taoism. Even then, though, if you want to make I Ching analogies, you probably want to talk about binary search trees, or allocation of identifiers by subdivision of a key space (like with IP addresses.)

Re: Was Alonzo Church Taoist?

#10
Others have pointed out the shallow connection to Taoism. But even the discussion of the lambda calculus does not seem to be insightful. For example, recursion in lambda calculus does not need names.
Post reply on HN