Live data from Hacker News

Hey Yahoo, Can you please open source Delicious?

web.archive.org

41–50 of 92 posts

Re: Hey Yahoo, Can you please open source Delicious?

#41

We are also compiling stories about present use cases of Delicious. If you are a user, post them here and I'll update the question.

When I bookmark a niche or obscure page, I can see the handful of other users that have also saved it. Because I can click through to their bookmarks, I often find a wealth of highly pertinent and (otherwise) hard to find links on the topic in question.

In other words, the whole social aspect.

Re: Hey Yahoo, Can you please open source Delicious?

#43
The actual code doesn't matter.

It's the tens of thousands of man hours that have been spent creating one of the best indexes with careful tags for millions of pages. The data's what makes Delicious matter.

And, if you open-source the data, I see people crying foul over privacy.

Re: Hey Yahoo, Can you please open source Delicious?

#44

I doubt we'll see it open sourced, or saved in any form by Yahoo. It's too much cost/effort for them, when that's the reason they're scrapping it in the first place. What i'd like to see is people quickly rolling out tools that help us get our Delicious bookmarks into other sites easier. Eg into Google Bookmarks. That currently requires you to install the Google Toolbar and import them through that (ugh).

You want a tool to do this job so you can avoid installing google toolbar? How much do you reckon thats worth to you?

Re: Hey Yahoo, Can you please open source Delicious?

#49

Google has open sourced: Jaiku, Etherpad, Wave among other things, before closing them down. Open sourcing it wouldn't solve the discovery/hosting part, but I still think they should do it. I'm sure it wouldn't be "easy," but it wouldn't be unprecedented. Yahoo! folks also should take a look at dataliberation.org, for best practices on getting on data out (also a Google joint). (Nope, I don't work for Google :D, just…

Data liberation is different from open-sourcing. Delicious allows you to dump every bit of metadata about your bookmarks either through their Data Export menu or via their API. Yahoo! did fine with Delicious in terms of data liberation. I imported all my bookmarks into pinboard.in without any trouble at all.

Re: Hey Yahoo, Can you please open source Delicious?

#50
post #43

The actual code doesn't matter. It's the tens of thousands of man hours that have been spent creating one of the best indexes with careful tags for millions of pages. The data's what makes Delicious matter. And, if you open-source the data, I see people crying foul over privacy.

Not if the links are public, which I suspect most people's are.
Post reply on HN