Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Day of the Tentacle

filfre.net

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–50 of 90 posts

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#41

Post by 0xADEADBEE »

okket wrote: post #37
Svip wrote: post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not necessary to have played Maniac Mansion beforehand? I'll admit this has been my main hesitation. I remember when Monkey Island III was big in the late 90s, I was hesitant because I hadn't played the two games that came before it. I ended up doing it anyway at the time, but later I would play all three, and the third one really benefits - in my view anyway - from having played the first two ones, even though…

You don't need to have played or know anything about Maniac Mansion to enjoy Day of the Tentacle. I would not even recommend to play MM first, because MM is stupendously hard and frustrating compared to DotT. Play it after. BTW: In the version of DotT I played in the 90s there was a funny easter egg: A computer in the game was running a playable version of Maniac Mansion. I don't know if this is part of the remastere…

It is! At least on the version I played from Steam :)

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#43

Post by Timberwolf »

okket wrote: post #37
Svip wrote: post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not necessary to have played Maniac Mansion beforehand? I'll admit this has been my main hesitation. I remember when Monkey Island III was big in the late 90s, I was hesitant because I hadn't played the two games that came before it. I ended up doing it anyway at the time, but later I would play all three, and the third one really benefits - in my view anyway - from having played the first two ones, even though…

You don't need to have played or know anything about Maniac Mansion to enjoy Day of the Tentacle. I would not even recommend to play MM first, because MM is stupendously hard and frustrating compared to DotT. Play it after. BTW: In the version of DotT I played in the 90s there was a funny easter egg: A computer in the game was running a playable version of Maniac Mansion. I don't know if this is part of the remastere…

Remastered has it too. Steam version even has achievements for doing things that require you to get a small way through the original.

Agree on not needing to play Maniac Mansion first, too. I came to the original having no idea that MM even existed. The characters and story are great even if you don't know the references.

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#44

Post by Timberwolf »

Maro wrote: post #19

Sam & Max, Day of the Tentacle, Full Throttle, floppy disks and dreaming of one day getting a huge 17" CRT monitor on a Pentium, that was my early teenage years.

I had a 17" CRT monitor on a 286, with a Trident 8900 SVGA card driving it. Hard to credit in these days, where even using a non SSD equipped computer is painful, I used to happily wait several seconds for Program Manager to repaint itself.

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#45

Post by qznc »

scoutt wrote: post #35
mr-ron wrote: post #10

This game captured a magical point in gaming where me my brother and my mother were playing on our PC, and my cousin and uncle were playing on another at the same time, keeping each other up to date on progress. We all were blocked at the same point until my uncle found the puzzle where you have to close a door to get the keys, and as soon as he found it he phoned my mom and we all progressed. That type of puzzle dis…

The puzzle that blocked me for days was that of reading some kind of boring manual to a horse to make it sleep. I still remember myself (a kid) jumping all around the room.

Boring manual? It was the dragon book!

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compilers:_Principles,_Techn...

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#46

Post by akavel »

To people considering buying it, given so much praise here and in the article, I would like to just ask you to take note of the following quote:

> "Of course, there’s no accounting for taste. If you loathe cartoons, perhaps you might not like this game. If you prefer more serious plots or more rigorously cerebral puzzles, perhaps you won’t love it. [...] It remains at the end of the day a slapstick cartoon comedy"

Personally, this caveat did apply so much to me. I bought and played the game, all way to the end, trying to give it a chance, but in my case, I found it plain boring. If you like slapstick, that's probably your gold nugget indeed, based on the glowing reviews. Me, I don't; I need at least some substance (?). I loved Loom, I enjoyed The Monkey Island (esp. the 1st one in the series), as well as the Indiana Jones games. I found amusement in their lightheartedness and casual humour. I liked Grim Fandango too. But DoTT fits the same place in my mind with Psychonauts: I plainly don't get why so many people are so stoked about them. To me, they're both just super boring.

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#47

Post by tomlong »

NamTaf wrote: post #4

Probably my favourite LA adventure game, though Sam & Max really does give it a run for its money. I played it at what I suspect was a very formative time of my pre-teens, and I think it did a lot to shape not only my humour, but also my understanding that games could be challenging yet satisfying in how they deliver a story through puzzles and obstacles. I think it struck a very good balance between a hand-holding p…

I'm 35 years old and had a similar experience. What you said about it shaping your humour really struck a chord with me (particularly Sam & Max). Maybe because it was the first LA game I played, but I think DoTT is the best, but it led to me playing all the rest.

I got the talkie on CD-ROM for a christmas present one year. I struggled with a lot of it, but my Dad before giving me the present removed the hint/solve book from the box and watched us (me and my younger brother) play and try and figure everything out and just gave us enough of a hint at the right times to make it feel like a really satisfying experience.

I'll RTFA after work.

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#48

Post by [deleted] »

theli0nheart wrote: post #6

This is one of my favorite games from my childhood. If you haven't ever played it, you owe it to yourself to purchase the remastered version [1] and play it through (it's only $3.79). It's incredibly entertaining and witty. I doubt this game will ever get stale. [1]: https://www.gog.com/game/day_of_the_tentacle_remastered

[deleted]

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#49

Post by chillydawg »

akavel wrote: post #46

To people considering buying it, given so much praise here and in the article, I would like to just ask you to take note of the following quote: > "Of course, there’s no accounting for taste. If you loathe cartoons, perhaps you might not like this game. If you prefer more serious plots or more rigorously cerebral puzzles, perhaps you won’t love it. [...] It remains at the end of the day a slapstick cartoon comedy" Pe…

I think it's probably to do with the fact that many of us here played it when it was first out and were either kids or much younger than we were now. My memory of that game is amazing, but I highly doubt I'd pick it up off the shelf today as my tastes have changed.

Re: Day of the Tentacle

#50

Post by PeterisP »

chillydawg wrote: post #49
akavel wrote: post #46

To people considering buying it, given so much praise here and in the article, I would like to just ask you to take note of the following quote: > "Of course, there’s no accounting for taste. If you loathe cartoons, perhaps you might not like this game. If you prefer more serious plots or more rigorously cerebral puzzles, perhaps you won’t love it. [...] It remains at the end of the day a slapstick cartoon comedy" Pe…

I think it's probably to do with the fact that many of us here played it when it was first out and were either kids or much younger than we were now. My memory of that game is amazing, but I highly doubt I'd pick it up off the shelf today as my tastes have changed.

I replayed it (the remastered version) some 20 years after initially playing it. It was still amazing.
Post reply on HN