Live data from Hacker News

Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

bbc.com

1–10 of 261 posts

Re: Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

#2
How about we start treating alcohol like smoking? For example ban alcohol advertising like we have with tobacco and I bet society would improve in a lot of unforeseen ways (besides the obvious reduction in alcohol related deaths and diseases and family issues).

Re: Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

#3
post #2

How about we start treating alcohol like smoking? For example ban alcohol advertising like we have with tobacco and I bet society would improve in a lot of unforeseen ways (besides the obvious reduction in alcohol related deaths and diseases and family issues).

[deleted]

Re: Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

#4
post #2

How about we start treating alcohol like smoking? For example ban alcohol advertising like we have with tobacco and I bet society would improve in a lot of unforeseen ways (besides the obvious reduction in alcohol related deaths and diseases and family issues).

Didn't we try that with prohibition?

Re: Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

#6
post #4
post #2

How about we start treating alcohol like smoking? For example ban alcohol advertising like we have with tobacco and I bet society would improve in a lot of unforeseen ways (besides the obvious reduction in alcohol related deaths and diseases and family issues).

Didn't we try that with prohibition?

Um, prohibition is the complete ban of all alcohol. umvi is proposing the ban of alcohol related advertising. One is completely different than the other.

Re: Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

#8
post #4
post #2

How about we start treating alcohol like smoking? For example ban alcohol advertising like we have with tobacco and I bet society would improve in a lot of unforeseen ways (besides the obvious reduction in alcohol related deaths and diseases and family issues).

Didn't we try that with prohibition?

Banning advertising of something is a bit different than banning the thing itself

Re: Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

#9
That's simply not going to happen because there is no "second hand sugar" scenario. Even alcohol, which is incredibly destructive to third parties by any measure (domestic abuse, drunk driving, etc), hasn't successfully been publicly vilified to the same extent as smoking.

Re: Is it time to treat sugar like smoking?

#10
post #4
post #2

How about we start treating alcohol like smoking? For example ban alcohol advertising like we have with tobacco and I bet society would improve in a lot of unforeseen ways (besides the obvious reduction in alcohol related deaths and diseases and family issues).

Didn't we try that with prohibition?

[deleted]
Post reply on HN