Live data from Hacker News

Dad, Are We Rich?

wealthydoc.org

121–130 of 164 posts

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#121
post #110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

plenty of people support a family on $60k/yr so take the remaining 440k minus taxes and buy two porsches outright. You should be able to save enough for a down-payment on each house given a year of saving.

No one supports a family on 60k a year. Healthcare alone for a family runs 20k/yr plus simply for insurance

You typically get free insurance when you have a job paying 500k/yr...

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Look up the 4% rule and firecalc.com to learn how this 100x multiple is a lot less, more like 25x realistically. A lot of people are irrationally intolerant of risk. Try not to let fear dominate your intuition about investing.

That 4% is empirically derived from data covering the 20th century and is appropriate for earlyish retirement. There's two reasons to be more conservative: 1) We may be in a low-yield world for a long time. 2) Those studies were based on earlier retirement, not on people leaving the workforce in their 20s and 30s, the way that some very lucky HN readers may do.

To follow up with your first point, there's been some analysis suggesting that financial markets today are more efficient than they were in the 20th century, which means that price discovery happens more quickly. Historically, the markets returned 8-10% for people invested in indices. I've heard that the market returns today are closer to 3-4%, so even with FIRE you'd realistically need to budget for 1-2% to accommodate for market fluctuations.

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Physician takes for granted that his profession has a monopoly on perscriptions and declaring medical necessity. >Laughably some consider me rich I know the article is supposed to hate on the 0.1%ers, but since Physicians always say this crap about their income, it's important to know Healthcare costs are terrible because he is paid so well.

I personally think health care costs are inflated by middlemen like insurance companies.

https://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Sta...

As far as I can tell, insurance companies are the only player in the system providing a check against the providers. The consumer has no idea what they're buying, so you need another similarly educated professional (employed by the insurance company) to vet the provider's charges. Insurance companies also have to spend 80% of their premiums on healthcare.

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Curious what decade? I was born in the 80s and that was the case in my Boston suburb - most people started out middle class, and where you ended up had more to with how smart & hardworking you were (and how much you took your good fortune for granted) than what your parents did. I'm not sure that holds for kids today, looking around at my Silicon Valley suburb. If you're a tech worker with a Ph.D from MIT, IIT, or Ch…

I grew up during the 90's and 2000's. I would hate to use Silicon Valley as an example for a normal american life. In most of America, you could give your kids pretty good opportunities without earning 500k. As for the immigrant mother struggling, this was true even 30 years ago when things were supposedly better.

Silicon Valley has a track record of being just like the rest of America, just 10-20 years ahead of it. My wife grew up here during the 80s and 90s; the middle-class lifestyle was very achievable then. When I compare her childhood with mine, it wasn't that different - the main differences are outdoor school hallways, bigger high schools (it was my school that was atypical here), more non-white people, and everybody liked hip-hop instead of rock music.

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#125

My kids asked me this and I said we are "comfortable". We are easily 1%-ers in terms of income level but we don't consider ourselves rich. I consider someone rich who has the luxury of not working and still maintaining a very good lifestyle. In Silicon Valley you can't do that without substantial net worth. The reason why we don't consider ourselves rich is because both my wife and I have to work very hard. We love o…

you are rich

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#126
post #110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No one supports a family on 60k a year. Healthcare alone for a family runs 20k/yr plus simply for insurance

You typically get free insurance when you have a job paying 500k/yr...

Its not free. CFO is very aware of your total cost and its starting to show up on W2's.

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#127
post #126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You typically get free insurance when you have a job paying 500k/yr...

Its not free. CFO is very aware of your total cost and its starting to show up on W2's.

that's besides that point? When you quote 500k/yr salary that typically includes perks like insurance. But are we really quibbling about $20k in expenses on a 500k salary? Even if I grant you 80k/yr to run your family that still leaves more than enough for your two porsches.

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#128
post #34

I think the HN bubble is far detached from the real world. If you own 100k+ of assets, most of the people in the world will see you as incredibly rich. If you own a house in the Bay Area even with a mortgage most Americans will see you as rich. Sure you might not feel rich because you have to go to the office each day and you dont have a sports car, but you are. Median and mean wealth per adult, in US dollars. USA: 6…

The Physician takes for granted that his profession has a monopoly on perscriptions and declaring medical necessity. >Laughably some consider me rich I know the article is supposed to hate on the 0.1%ers, but since Physicians always say this crap about their income, it's important to know Healthcare costs are terrible because he is paid so well.

Doctors are way overpaid. The barriers to entry to become a physician are un-necessarily high, and I have a suspicion that that's by design. You only need a moderate amount of intelligence to learn and apply medicine. If the barriers to entry were lowered, then physician salaries would fall precipitously as supply would outgrow demand.

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#129
post #100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>My measure of rich is "Can I live my current lifestyle without regular income from a job?" I would say that's wealthy. Rich, to me, is if you have the means to buy and do what you want for a reasonable set of desires. In other words, you can buy a nice house in a nice area, drive a new luxuryish (i.e. BMW level) car, go on vacations, and buy stuff like a big TV without worrying. Somewhere between 150k and 300k salar…

So then if you lose your job you're no longer rich? Are you then poor? The problem, to me, in differentiating rich vs wealthy based on how you get your money is that it makes things too fluid.

But to me (at least) how you get your money is the fundamental difference. The rich guy has to go to work - the wealthy guy has to do whatever he wants.

Re: Dad, Are We Rich?

#130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Physician takes for granted that his profession has a monopoly on perscriptions and declaring medical necessity. >Laughably some consider me rich I know the article is supposed to hate on the 0.1%ers, but since Physicians always say this crap about their income, it's important to know Healthcare costs are terrible because he is paid so well.

Doctors are way overpaid. The barriers to entry to become a physician are un-necessarily high, and I have a suspicion that that's by design. You only need a moderate amount of intelligence to learn and apply medicine. If the barriers to entry were lowered, then physician salaries would fall precipitously as supply would outgrow demand.

Disclaimer: I'm married to a doctor. That said, I agree with your point that they are over-paid, but I absolutely don't agree with the idea that you only need a moderate amount of intelligence to work as a physician. A slight majority of my friend group is physicians, both through my spouse's education and work and through a collegiate friend group that mostly went into medicine. While I have many, many complaints about the medical profession and many of the people who work at it, they are, virtually without exception, extremely intelligent people. The ones who weren't washed out at some point in the 4 years of university and subsequent 8-12 years of training. Some of the barriers to entry are excessive, but most of them are there because being a doctor is incredibly difficult.
Post reply on HN