Live data from Hacker News

Apple Pro Display XDR

techcrunch.com

51–60 of 160 posts

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#51

Apple is just completely out of touch now, aren't they?

This is not for consumers. This is for AV industry professionals whose companies are footing the bill. Apple has, rightly, been under fire lately for forgetting about the pro market. This display, in the context of the presentation, is intended to demonstrate that their professional focus is back.

I am not an AV industry professional. Are there competitive displays now? How much do they cost?

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#52
post #8

You could hear a gasp in the crowd when they listed $999 for the stand alone. Apple is certainly pushing themselves up-market with this one.

"Pro"

Fairly predictable. Commodified tablets for consumers, laptops for developers (still working on that...), hugely expensive thoroughbred (status symbol) hardware for professional content creators with professional budgets.

Problem is, there's much more money in the prosumer niche than there is at the high end. For every successful LA movie score composer there are thousands, even tens of thousands, of bedroom DAW users.

What "pros" really want is outstanding performance at an affordable price. This is outstanding performance at a painful price - which is a novel combination of aspirational and incredibly annoying.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#53

The “XDR” part of the name seems a bit out of place for an Apple product. I guess I’m stuck in the past and Apple is really a different company now.

It will take me some time to not think of “extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis” when I hear XDR: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extensively_drug-resistant_tub...

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#55
post #5

I'm hearing that the LG displays were running out of stock, possibly in anticipation of a new Apple display. Sure enough...wait a minute, FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS?! Oh, I understand it's a reference-quality, blah, blah, blah, but I just need something to replace an aging Cinema display that was originally $1000. The fucking stand for the new display costs that much (note the audience response when that price popped on t…

I think this thing is completing against stuff like the 10 bit 4k Eizos which are also pretty expensive to use for anything other the highend graphics. They probably should have a none hdr model for half the price though.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#56
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Eizos are outstanding. You can find pretty good deals on used ones with good color space coverage.

EIZO is definitely great, but 4K EIZO screens ain't exactly cheap either. Closest to consumer-level are the CG248-4K and CG318-4K (which actually are reference-grade) and cost about $2,800.

The consumer-level Flexscan series are much cheaper. The EV3285, for example, is retailing for $1800 on BHPhoto.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#57
post #8

You could hear a gasp in the crowd when they listed $999 for the stand alone. Apple is certainly pushing themselves up-market with this one.

"Pro" Fairly predictable. Commodified tablets for consumers, laptops for developers (still working on that...), hugely expensive thoroughbred (status symbol) hardware for professional content creators with professional budgets. Problem is, there's much more money in the prosumer niche than there is at the high end. For every successful LA movie score composer there are thousands, even tens of thousands, of bedroom DA…

Pros can justify the price if the performance is top-of-the-line and downtime is zero (or support & fix is near-instant).

If Apple's quality control game leaks over into this new Pro line, then there will be lots of unhappy professionals staring at their $11k paperweights while shopping for something else.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#58
post #5

I'm hearing that the LG displays were running out of stock, possibly in anticipation of a new Apple display. Sure enough...wait a minute, FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS?! Oh, I understand it's a reference-quality, blah, blah, blah, but I just need something to replace an aging Cinema display that was originally $1000. The fucking stand for the new display costs that much (note the audience response when that price popped on t…

Just to be sure, you get that this display isn't targeted at developers? :)

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#59
post #21
post #5

I'm hearing that the LG displays were running out of stock, possibly in anticipation of a new Apple display. Sure enough...wait a minute, FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS?! Oh, I understand it's a reference-quality, blah, blah, blah, but I just need something to replace an aging Cinema display that was originally $1000. The fucking stand for the new display costs that much (note the audience response when that price popped on t…

Why not just buy a 4K monitor from another company?

Because 4K doesn’t pixel double and the 5K display selection is somewhere between sparse and nonexistent.
Post reply on HN