Live data from Hacker News

My Startup - A node.js cloud hosting platform

nodejscloud.com

11–20 of 36 posts

Re: My Startup - A node.js cloud hosting platform

#14

Why do you think you got rejected? It seems like a really good idea.

Doesn't it seem a bit "me too"ish? Seems like a super crowded market with extremely capable competitors. Heroku was able to sneak in since they were the first company to offer a service like this for rails. With Joyent's amazing no.de platform, I can't imagine any business deciding to base their infrastructure on a tool that a couple developers just started and doesn't yet have stable funding or a proven business.

Just my 2 cents. The landing page looks great. Hope they can pull through.

Re: My Startup - A node.js cloud hosting platform

#15
post #14

Why do you think you got rejected? It seems like a really good idea.

Doesn't it seem a bit "me too"ish? Seems like a super crowded market with extremely capable competitors. Heroku was able to sneak in since they were the first company to offer a service like this for rails. With Joyent's amazing no.de platform, I can't imagine any business deciding to base their infrastructure on a tool that a couple developers just started and doesn't yet have stable funding or a proven business. Ju…

Not an RoR user but wasn't Engine Yard there before Heroku? I am assuming Engine Yard and Heroku offer something similar. I might be wrong.

Re: My Startup - A node.js cloud hosting platform

#18
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn't it seem a bit "me too"ish? Seems like a super crowded market with extremely capable competitors. Heroku was able to sneak in since they were the first company to offer a service like this for rails. With Joyent's amazing no.de platform, I can't imagine any business deciding to base their infrastructure on a tool that a couple developers just started and doesn't yet have stable funding or a proven business. Ju…

Not an RoR user but wasn't Engine Yard there before Heroku? I am assuming Engine Yard and Heroku offer something similar. I might be wrong.

EngineYard was doing uber expensive fully managed rails hosting at the time Heroku go started. Wasn't till over a year after Heroku launched that EY launched their alternative (Solo->Cloud->??). Pretty good tools, but fairly different than Heroku. They focus on managing EC2 instances instead of Heroku's "Dynos" (small abstracted chunks of easily scalable server resources).

To me EY seems like a much better version of Linode + install scripts that are targeted to Ruby users. Heroku seems to me more like Google's AppEngine, except much more expensive and without the autoscaling.

Re: My Startup - A node.js cloud hosting platform

#19
post #17

It's a nice page design and all, but on top of the solutions provided by Heroku and Joyent, there already exists NodeJitsu, which seems pretty solid. Are you offering anything different here? Seems like a bit of "me too" syndrome. http://nodejitsu.com/

I'll chime in here although I might be a bit biased ( co-founder of Nodejitsu).

I'm always glad to see more attention to node.js, but it's a bit discouraging to see something like this with no substance to back it up.

The Nodejitsu team has been working on our node.js platform as a service for a while now, and we've released a bunch of open-source software back to the community along the way.

http://github.com/nodejitsu/

http://blog.nodejitsu.com/

I'd rather go with a trusted source than a company who struggles with basic git knowledge.

http://groups.google.com/group/nodejs/browse_thread/thread/5...

Post reply on HN