Live data from Hacker News

Getting my personal data out of Facebook

ruben.verborgh.org

21–30 of 77 posts

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#21
Under the GDPR, each country has a Data Protection Authority set up in order to enforce and supervise these rules.

The author needs to contact his country's DPA and they will be the ones to drop the hammer on Facebook.

Facebook might not listen to an end user, but European governmental authorities have the power to force them to.

It's the only logical next step in my opinion.

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#23
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What exactly are they afraid of? Exposing the level of detail in the data accumulated. This starts at "opened the messenger app at this location on this date&time" and goes to "visited this Facebook-unrelated website on these times". Having to provide all of this data exposes the detailed profile they're getting on people.

They are only getting what you are giving to them. If you decide to browse the web without uBlock Origin or if you decide to use Android, you know what you're being exposed to.

> If you decide to browse the web without uBlock Origin or if you decide to use Android, you know what you're being exposed to.

Time to step out of the bubble of tech-savvy people and talk to everyday users. It's unrealistic to assume everybody understands technical consequences, and it's unreasonable to require everybody to do so. That's why there is regulation. This applies to all fields, including medicine, food, and IT.

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#24

It's a very interesting web page. But it would be better told without all the sarcasm and invective. I understand the author's need to vent his spleen, but he should create a second, more black-and-white version that comes off as more credible and is less easily dismissed.

Yeah, I enjoyed the story telling but the sarcasm watered it down as a ragey customer who was being unreasonable—and it made it really hard to read. If you want to get a company to ignore you, all you have to do is get pissy, and it's clearly what's going on here.

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#25
It seems like Facebook has staked out a legal position on this. A dubious one likely to fail and doubtless designed mostly to buy time, but a legal position nonetheless, which will only be struck down by a court, not an email reply chain.

You had me up until the legalese email, after which the correct response is to sue. You lost me with the belligerent reply ranting about what Mark said in the Washington Post. It seems, at that point, that you're more interested in grandstanding than making a defensible case.

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#26

What you are asking for does not seem unreasonable, quite the opposite. What exactly are they afraid of?

Well for a start it would involve not being able to keep denying shadow profiles exist, and the joining up of some not especially well understood programmes. Like being able to connect up all those facebook bugs and third party logins to get large parts of your off Facebook activity. Then maybe exposing some of the third party quizzes, VPN's, and privacy apps that have poured more into the data vats. Possibly exposin…

Someone asked Zuck during the congressional hearings about shadow profiles (worded as data about people who don't have Facebook accounts).. he deflected and said something like "I'll get back to you on that.".

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#27
post #4

Who else could wade through the sea of garbage you people produce, retrieve valuable truths and even interpret their meaning for later generations?

‘you people’ is an invective that apparently excludes yourself from the class you refer to. You don’t visit web pages?

http://junkerhq.net/MGS2/Text.html

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#28

Under the GDPR, each country has a Data Protection Authority set up in order to enforce and supervise these rules. The author needs to contact his country's DPA and they will be the ones to drop the hammer on Facebook. Facebook might not listen to an end user, but European governmental authorities have the power to force them to. It's the only logical next step in my opinion.

That's all well and good, until you realise the actual resources the DPA's are working under. Here in Finland it's a tiny organisation [1] and it was reported that they are completely overwhelmed with all the problems post-GDPR.

[1] https://tietosuoja.fi/etusivu

Re: Getting my personal data out of Facebook

#30

Under the GDPR, each country has a Data Protection Authority set up in order to enforce and supervise these rules. The author needs to contact his country's DPA and they will be the ones to drop the hammer on Facebook. Facebook might not listen to an end user, but European governmental authorities have the power to force them to. It's the only logical next step in my opinion.

Ah no. The EU countries have agreed, that the home country of the organization (not the country of the data subject) will take the lead in any GDPR enforcement.

Facebook in EU is registered in Ireland.

Ireland is making a mockery of GDPR, slow walking investigations while paying lip service to GDPR.

Ireland is a leech. They've figured out that they can attract global companies through very lenient tax auditing and (now) GDPR enforcement. A little tax is better than none. As such they are undermining the rest of EU when it comes to actions against companies like Facebook, Google, Microsoft.

Post reply on HN