Live data from Hacker News

Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

zdnet.com

91–99 of 99 posts

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#91
post #70

This is why we are building 100% offline and private-by-design Voice AI at https://snips.ai , it is free for makers and works in english, french, german, japanese, spanish, italian, and more coming!

Which voice engine do you use?

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#92
post #48
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I fairness to your bed time reading example, it’s very common for people to have bed side lights - even if they’re just little lamps that rest on a table. At least this is the norm in the UK. So for a great many of us, turning our reading light out would just be an extension of our arm. My wife tends to prefer using the TV as her reading light. I find that rather bizarre but she likes the background noise. In any cas…

Why am I getting downvoted? Do people disagree that it’s common for bedrooms to have lamps? A little context would be appreciated because my comment is 100% accurate in terms my own experiences yet several people seem to disagree. Genuinely interested to know why.

I didn't downvote, but just to answer- yes, I have a nightstand light, like most bedrooms here in the US. However, I also use a CPAP machine, and it is a genuine convenience to be able to put it on with the lights on, then use words to shut the lights off instead of reaching over to the side and having to deal with a slightly-too-short hose length. And frankly it's nice to not have to leave one's blanket cocoon for light/dark, not even it a little.

A small thing? Sure. But it is a genuine comfort that I enjoy.

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#93
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, for me, it is a glorified cooking timer and alarm clock. If I could buy a closed unit that just did that, then I would be happy.

You mean.... your phone, right?

I don't want to touch the phone with raw meat juice; voice commands plus learning to cook has the potential for amazingness.

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#94
post #70

This is why we are building 100% offline and private-by-design Voice AI at https://snips.ai , it is free for makers and works in english, french, german, japanese, spanish, italian, and more coming!

I don't see any guarantee that if the platform gets popular and the company acquired, privacy would stay the same. I have seen the same pattern too many times...

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#95
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why am I getting downvoted? Do people disagree that it’s common for bedrooms to have lamps? A little context would be appreciated because my comment is 100% accurate in terms my own experiences yet several people seem to disagree. Genuinely interested to know why.

I didn't downvote, but just to answer- yes, I have a nightstand light, like most bedrooms here in the US. However, I also use a CPAP machine, and it is a genuine convenience to be able to put it on with the lights on, then use words to shut the lights off instead of reaching over to the side and having to deal with a slightly-too-short hose length. And frankly it's nice to not have to leave one's blanket cocoon for l…

To be honest I’d lump you into the same as the caveat made earlier about people with physical disabilities because even though you’re (presumably) able bodied, at night time your movement is restricted.

I can totally see the benefit for people in circumstances like your own (and those with greater concerns too). But for the average Joe? That’s another matter. Like any accessibility tool, I agree they are fantastic for those who depend upon it. However I wouldn’t advocate everyone gets a blind dog, hearing aid or wheelchair unless they actually needed it. Similarly would you actually want an Echo device in your bedroom if you didn’t have the accessibility concern that your CPAP machine creates?

Ultimately it’s harder to justify that privacy vs convenience trade off when accessibility isn’t an issue. But I accept that’s a decision which will be as divided as it will be personal. Myself; I have an Echo in the kitchen but I have no interest in allowing them to migrate upstairs.

Also thanks for the response. I do appreciate reading someone else’s perspective:)

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#96
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mean.... your phone, right?

I don't want to touch the phone with raw meat juice; voice commands plus learning to cook has the potential for amazingness.

I'm going to presume that you have Siri enabled... no touching required, right? Just knuckle the thing. Curl the pinky finger and tap w/ the knuckle. 0_o

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#97
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mean.... your phone, right?

A cellphone is pretty much the absolute nadir of "closed unit" devices (in the sense the prior poster was describing) that could be possibly imagined.

How else would you use the word "nadir"

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#98
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't want to touch the phone with raw meat juice; voice commands plus learning to cook has the potential for amazingness.

I'm going to presume that you have Siri enabled... no touching required, right? Just knuckle the thing. Curl the pinky finger and tap w/ the knuckle. 0_o

I don't have Siri, and I generally don't have my phone near me all the time. Same for the wife, it's super awesome to just be able to talk to Alexa. I share the privacy concerns, so I am hopeful https://mycroft.ai being a suitable replacement as I have ordered and plan to build a better rig to handle the deepspeech.

Re: Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions

#99
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A cellphone is pretty much the absolute nadir of "closed unit" devices (in the sense the prior poster was describing) that could be possibly imagined.

How else would you use the word "nadir"

"Lowest point" basically.

I.e. "Political threads are the nadir of discussion on HN"

Post reply on HN