Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

AirPods Are a Tragedy

vice.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 35 posts

Re: AirPods Are a Tragedy

#2

Post by stinos »

Much of what gets laid out in the article is also true for a whole range of other disposable products of different types. Take plastic bottles, essentially the same tragedy. Companies like Apple did and still do fairly well when it comes to innovation and planting ideas in people's head. If only they would use that creativity to make it cool again to own less products which at the same last longer and are upgradable/servicable, some of the tragedy could be alleviated.

Re: AirPods Are a Tragedy

#4

Post by dngray »

I see so many teenagers these days with those things in their ears. It makes me facepalm every time I see it.

Makes me feel good that I got such a good deal on my Audio-Technica ATH-IM04s.

They were normally $700 US but now they are end-of-life I got a new pair for only $391 US. win. The retailer was trying to get rid of them as they were end-of-life stock.

Re: AirPods Are a Tragedy

#5

Post by nanaya »

stinos wrote: post #2

Much of what gets laid out in the article is also true for a whole range of other disposable products of different types. Take plastic bottles, essentially the same tragedy. Companies like Apple did and still do fairly well when it comes to innovation and planting ideas in people's head. If only they would use that creativity to make it cool again to own less products which at the same last longer and are upgradable/…

Here's difference between airpods and plastic bottles:

> They can’t be repaired because they're glued together. They can’t be thrown out, or else the lithium-ion battery may start a fire in the garbage compactor. They can’t be easily recycled, because there’s no safe way to separate the lithium-ion battery from the plastic shell.

Re: AirPods Are a Tragedy

#6

Post by zoul »

Jesus, that’s a really bad article, spinning some truths, irrelevant info and memes into hate. Most of what’s written applies to all wireless headphones, wired headphones or even other consumer electronics. Also, Apple has a recycling program. Would it be too much journalism to say why it doesn’t change the situation? If they managed to recycle most of the AirPods, then I’m mostly happy with the product, and it’s entirely my fault if it ends up on a landfill.

True, I would wish the headphones to be more repairable, but there’s a big difference between designing a repairable washing machine and repairable wireless headphones. The design constraints are pretty tight I imagine.

Writing such hateful and poor quality articles is not going to improve anything.

Re: AirPods Are a Tragedy

#7

Post by zoul »

nanaya wrote: post #5
stinos wrote: post #2

Much of what gets laid out in the article is also true for a whole range of other disposable products of different types. Take plastic bottles, essentially the same tragedy. Companies like Apple did and still do fairly well when it comes to innovation and planting ideas in people's head. If only they would use that creativity to make it cool again to own less products which at the same last longer and are upgradable/…

Here's difference between airpods and plastic bottles: > They can’t be repaired because they're glued together. They can’t be thrown out, or else the lithium-ion battery may start a fire in the garbage compactor. They can’t be easily recycled, because there’s no safe way to separate the lithium-ion battery from the plastic shell.

It would be interesting to ask Apple how much they manage to recycle from the AirPods and how. Would that be asking too much from the article author?

Re: AirPods Are a Tragedy

#9

Post by bb101 »

dngray wrote: post #4

I see so many teenagers these days with those things in their ears. It makes me facepalm every time I see it. Makes me feel good that I got such a good deal on my Audio-Technica ATH-IM04s. They were normally $700 US but now they are end-of-life I got a new pair for only $391 US. win. The retailer was trying to get rid of them as they were end-of-life stock.

I felt the same way before I tried Airpods. They are ridiculously useful and convenient, and they don't sound bad either. For me, it's a tiny device to use for hands-free phone calls and indulge in music on the go without having to lug another large device around.

Re: AirPods Are a Tragedy

#10

Post by dngray »

bb101 wrote: post #9
dngray wrote: post #4

I see so many teenagers these days with those things in their ears. It makes me facepalm every time I see it. Makes me feel good that I got such a good deal on my Audio-Technica ATH-IM04s. They were normally $700 US but now they are end-of-life I got a new pair for only $391 US. win. The retailer was trying to get rid of them as they were end-of-life stock.

I felt the same way before I tried Airpods. They are ridiculously useful and convenient, and they don't sound bad either. For me, it's a tiny device to use for hands-free phone calls and indulge in music on the go without having to lug another large device around.

> hands-free phone calls and indulge in music on the go without having to lug another large device around

You've pretty much described any ear-bud/canal earphone.

The point is there's choices that have removable batteries, and aren't so wasteful. 18 months is a pathetic lifetime.

Post reply on HN