Live data from Hacker News

B&H Launching Payboo to Combat Online Taxes

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 63 posts

Re: B&H Launching Payboo to Combat Online Taxes

#51
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are trying to shift the seller from being B&H to individual consumers who can more frequently be exempt from collecting sales tax.

I understand the confusion but this is not the case at all. B&H is the seller and each individual customer is the buyer. -- Henry Posner / B&H Photo-Video

Thank you for the clarification Henry. Indeed I was speculating on the nature of the service based on the wording of the service description in the trademark application and now that the new details have been released, we have a much better understanding about payboo. Very interesting concept indeed although I believe the trademark service description is a little misleading.

Re: B&H Launching Payboo to Combat Online Taxes

#52
post #6

I was seriously so confused my this e-mail. I've found great deals on B&H in the past but getting e-mails telling me about a neat trick to evade taxes leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

So after jumping to conclusions about tax evasion, it turns out it's just a cash back credit card. You were so far off.

Re: B&H Launching Payboo to Combat Online Taxes

#53
post #49

Sounds like a cash back store card. Amazon gives 5%. Bh just has to do a bit more to cancel out taxes.

Yup that's exactly what it is. This was so underwhelming. I guess 9% back is really good if you buy a ton from b&h but I'm definitely not opening a credit card for a random store like that.

Re: B&H Launching Payboo to Combat Online Taxes

#55
I got an official response on how it works:

Thanks for your interest in B&H Photo and for this feedback. Like most of our customers I want the benefits of the tax revenue when my state paves roads, improves schools, and so on. Like most of our customers I'd also like to have as much of my hard-earned dollars in my pocket as possible.

The Payboo program does not change when or how much your state treasury receives from a purchase made here. State sales tax is paid as it was yesterday and last week but now, when that's done B&H issues an "instant rebate" to you for the amount of tax you just paid.

--

regards, Henry Posner Director of Corporate Communications B&H Photo-Video, and Pro-Audio http://www.bandh.com/

Re: B&H Launching Payboo to Combat Online Taxes

#59

I am rather surprised that so many users here--who are presumably some of the smarter people out there--supposed that from this email that B&H had found some sort of "loophole" or "workaround," twisting themselves into pretzels thinking about it, rather than simply assuming as a default that it was some sort of discounting promotion gimmick. That was the only thing that came to my mind from square one as soon as I re…

Because the marketing around Playboo as being a "new business to solve the tax problem" doesn't necessarily seem to trigger - hey I'm going to give you a discount if you pay via our preferred financier. The initial email announcement around this just seemed to make it feel like some kind of shell game.

IMO, Now that details are out, the way it is positioned, standing up a whole other line of business/partnership for the sole purpose of providing a credit line in addition to what amounts to a Unless a vast number of orders are currently financed, I don't know how Synchrony makes money on this partnership unless there's a disproportionate amount of folks that don't pay off their purchase via this Payboo immediately and incur interest charges - which would reduce the "sales-tax savings" as a reward. If there's already a lot of "financed purchases" - that "sales-tax savings" is just part of the introductory rate on a purchase via Synchrony and just translates into even more shared revenue between B&H and Synchrony.

Post reply on HN