Live data from Hacker News

An Amateur Porno Set Off a Federal Witch Hunt

thedailybeast.com

11–20 of 71 posts

Re: An Amateur Porno Set Off a Federal Witch Hunt

#11
Summary: Young man has a passion & dream to make movies. He has a thriving business but it's not enough to fund the movie. His friends agree to fund a movie but with a clause - it must be a porno movie.

He researches existing literature and it sucks. He won't make porn. He'll make a real movie that also has explicit sex.

He shoots normal scenes first, and sex scenes later. Sex scenes has some issues like the actors unable to get erection and him not knowing how to direct the scenes.

Movie is finished. He edits, distribution says he must include at least one lesbian scene, some cum shots... things he'd cut out.

Movie is a success in theaters and gets sold out every single day and then all hell breaks loose. The police comes after him. Lots of complaints were sent to officials - some by people who hadn't actually watched the movie.

The film maker had used a property owned by the church without permission and the church was the force behind the investigations.

The court case was a sham. The investigators invokes anti-fornication laws 100s of years old. And the cops (probably) sets the film maker up.

One of the lead actors commits suicide just as the case becomes a federal one. The government takes all the earnings of the film, fines him, bans him from film making for a few years and gives him a suspended jail sentence.

Re: An Amateur Porno Set Off a Federal Witch Hunt

#13
post #10

What's "amateur" about that? It seems that the word appears only in the title. Edit: he had a $25k budget at least (over $150k adjusted for inflation) and while it was his first movie he hired professional performers and the intention was the commercial exhibition of the film in movie theaters (as it did happen).

He was clearly an amateur since he had never made any kind of movie.

But his intent was to make a professional/commercial film.

They are not necessarily disjoint concepts.

To top that off, at the end of the interview he gives himself a humorous critique suggesting he found his own work failed to make the professional grade.

Re: An Amateur Porno Set Off a Federal Witch Hunt

#14
post #12

The more I learn about the 1970s the more the 1980s makes sense to me.

I was born in the 80s so I have zero context for either decade.

Recently watched the CNN documentaries on each decade and it was truly eye opening how nuts things were essentially every decade in one way or another. But above all of then, the 70s seemed like the WEIRDEST time to me.

Highly recommend the documentaries - super informative. Was fun to re-live the 90s and 00s a bit too.

Re: An Amateur Porno Set Off a Federal Witch Hunt

#17
post #10

What's "amateur" about that? It seems that the word appears only in the title. Edit: he had a $25k budget at least (over $150k adjusted for inflation) and while it was his first movie he hired professional performers and the intention was the commercial exhibition of the film in movie theaters (as it did happen).

He was clearly an amateur since he had never made any kind of movie. But his intent was to make a professional/commercial film. They are not necessarily disjoint concepts. To top that off, at the end of the interview he gives himself a humorous critique suggesting he found his own work failed to make the professional grade.

I wouldn't classify as "amateur" a commercial movie where the lead roles are played by professional actors, but that may be just me. The downvotes I got agree with you. (Being a bad movie may make it look "amateurish", but that's something different.)

Re: An Amateur Porno Set Off a Federal Witch Hunt

#18
post #10

What's "amateur" about that? It seems that the word appears only in the title. Edit: he had a $25k budget at least (over $150k adjusted for inflation) and while it was his first movie he hired professional performers and the intention was the commercial exhibition of the film in movie theaters (as it did happen).

That's pretty typical start in the film industry in that era which would very much be amateur.

Not everyone had cheap digital cameras, not to mention cheap video editing on computers to start out back then. Only in the early 1990s did random non-actors in the director's first "indie" films start becoming more normal.

Re: An Amateur Porno Set Off a Federal Witch Hunt

#20
post #19

How unapologetic the prosecutor still is offends me. Trying to use anti fornication laws from 1796 and knowing it's a miscarriage of justice? Yet still thinks it's the right decision.

And he has blood on his hands. One of the actors committed suicide.

There should have been some prosecution: not of the film maker, but on those who abused their power to harass people to the point of suicide.

Post reply on HN