Live data from Hacker News

60 days in jail for not paying a $2.75 subway fare costs the city $22,000

twitter.com

121–123 of 123 posts

Re: 60 days in jail for not paying a $2.75 subway fare costs the city $22,000

#121
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have them spend a shift cleaning garbage. Done.

I see we're leaning real hard into that "except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted" thing.

Okay, good point. I was being far too glib.

Re: 60 days in jail for not paying a $2.75 subway fare costs the city $22,000

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If the provided lunch is any good, then yes, a good thing. Could some families afford the cost and time of providing a better 2-4 course lunch every day? Sure, but most won’t.

As a child, I had a wide array of food allergies, so doctors put me on a so-called rotation diet. I could only be exposed to certain food items once every 4 days. Day 1 of the cycle allowed wheat and rye, so on the other days, I could not eat any dish with sauce bound with wheat flour. (My family used carob seed flour instead.) Day 2 was potatoes, day 3 was corn, day 4 was rice. (Those were the most significant items…

It’s probably similar to the Nordics. Which is that it’s the schools responsibility to cater to your needs, no matter the costs. Just be sure to have a doctors note.

Re: 60 days in jail for not paying a $2.75 subway fare costs the city $22,000

#123
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why not fine them instead? Before you say, not everyone can afford XYZ fine. I would fully support a income based proportional fine system in the US. What i Don't support is putting someone in jail because they can't afford a lawyer.

What do you do about people with no money? With BART especially, you can watch the same person that jumped the gate light up a meth pipe in the back of the train car. BART police will kick them off the train if they get caught but can't really do much else since the city doesn't really prosecute for drug offenses. If you look at the arrest records, you see the same people arrested day after day. They don't have any m…

I like this suggestion as well. People without money can instead do community service instead.
Post reply on HN