Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

bloomberg.com

121–130 of 353 posts

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#121
post #19
post #2

Satya has done a tremendous job turning around Microsoft. It was headed in the direction of becoming a slowly sinking behemoth under Ballmer, but he's turned it around. Sundar, on the other hand, is just content collecting $$ and showing more ads.

In what way was MS sinking under Ballmer? Maybe they were not exciting but they were super profitable every year. I think it's more about better PR. Not everything is golden at MS now either. I am working on creating a platform for our medical software on Windows 10 and it really makes me want to switch to Linux or iOS. Windows is a big mess of old and new code and attempts of sandboxing like iOS but only half-hearte…

Remember this comic: https://amp.businessinsider.com/images/50a25c45eab8ea8c41000...

Ballmer brewed the culture to be like that.

It's not like that at MSFT anymore.

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#123
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If people don't pay for software maintenance, e.g. Windows 10 updates, what do you do? Ads, harvest data... Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee. You can buy a Windows computer incl. services at a price point you can only dream of Apple hardware. Facebook/Inst/Wapp and Google show that the majority of people go with 'Geiz ist geil' (cheap is cool), privacy be damned. Awareness doesn't necessar…

Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data. This mindset is toxic and needs to die.

[disclosure, MS employee]

With the absence of telemetry, how do you know Linux is doing just fine? (specifically in the desktop world, not server world).

Microsoft has an interest in knowing how well Windows is doing, and Windows has lived in a world both with and without telemetry. It was way, way harder to gauge success prior to telemetry, and it was also much more frustrating for the user to communicate their problems. I don't think Windows could have stayed in the pre-telemetry engineering world and maintained its position as a competitive desktop OS.

I ask this mostly out of ignorance, I've got experience using Linux, but I really don't know what the dev-loop is like for active engineers.

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#124
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In what way was MS sinking under Ballmer? Maybe they were not exciting but they were super profitable every year. I think it's more about better PR. Not everything is golden at MS now either. I am working on creating a platform for our medical software on Windows 10 and it really makes me want to switch to Linux or iOS. Windows is a big mess of old and new code and attempts of sandboxing like iOS but only half-hearte…

> In what way was MS sinking under Ballmer? In a relative way. If you are going to talk about operating systems, iOS and Android/Linux blew by Windows on his watch despite Microsoft's big head start in the smartphone space. I think that's directly the result of Microsoft not being exciting.

MS also had a big head start on Tablets: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Tablet_PC

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#125
post #48

I'm failing to see what has changed. Point is that they still make the lion share of their revenue from milking PC OEMs and plumpy corporate clients. The fact that they changed tools for doing so, does not change the scheme at large. Their hosting service Azure just took over their AD and sharepoint clients with some extra being the genuine new clientele I'd say that under Nadella, they grew even more recalcitrant, a…

“A lot of oldtimer MS devs I knew say that now they got a genuine fear of every new tech coming from MS almost customarily becoming an abandonware in 2-3 years term.” That’s how I have been feeling from around the time WPF came out... And they reinforce that fear regularly.

UWP feels like it’s going to be abandonware.

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#126
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nadella has made a few key changes, for example exempting internal product teams from having to consider Windows as the only OS to develop for, changed the incentive structure for sales to avoid pushing products enterprises didn't care about etc... When you're a CEO your success is usually not dependent by flashy all in decisions, especially if you're managing a giant company like MS. You are successful by setting po…

I think they are in danger of neglecting Windows too much to the point of people leaving the platform. I personally wouldn't recommend Windows anymore. And almost nobody who isn't using Windows will use azure or .NET Core.

> And almost nobody who isn't using Windows will use azure or .NET Core.

I disagree with this too. I've been looking into .NET Core since it's been open sourced. And I'd consider Azure. But I certainly won't be using windows (for server stuff) unless I'm forced to.

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#127

Having read Nadella's book Hit Refresh as soon as it went on sale, Microsoft performance since then doesn't look surprising at all. Having listed what's wrong (with their product focus, company culture etc), and where they plan to head, its' almost like the book informs the reader where puck is going to be (from Satya's POV). It's funny that 15 years back I was so anti MS and pro Google and now I think it's the other…

“It's funny that 15 years back I was so anti MS and pro Google and now I think it's the other way!” Stay skeptical of all of them. No need to be fan of one of the big techs. In the end they are all greedy organizations that want to dominate. None of them should be trusted.

I'm both wary of and hopeful about Microsoft and Google.

"Trust but verify" and all that.

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#128

What a great difference between him and Ballmer. I'd not be surprised if they eat Amazon's lunch on cloud computing in the next few years.

I would never, ever underestimate Andy Jassy. I consider him on par with Jeff Bezos, in terms of leadership and execution, if not superior. source: worked at AWS 2008-2014.

How is he superior?

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Possible, but from the inside as a Microsoft Partner, it feels like most of the world is just starting to move to the cloud, and when they do, they go Azure, because they are already dependent on Exchange.

Odd, I'm seeing more and more people trying to find ways to escape Exchange, and not having it as a driver towards anything. Nobody likes being driven by artificial lock-ins.

What are some viable alternatives? OpenLDAP?

Re: Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance

#130
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If people don't pay for software maintenance, e.g. Windows 10 updates, what do you do? Ads, harvest data... Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee. You can buy a Windows computer incl. services at a price point you can only dream of Apple hardware. Facebook/Inst/Wapp and Google show that the majority of people go with 'Geiz ist geil' (cheap is cool), privacy be damned. Awareness doesn't necessar…

Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data. This mindset is toxic and needs to die.

> Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data.

Ugh. I am quite proficient with tech stuff, but last month trying Ubuntu 18.04 LTS on my desktop left me pretty disappointed. A hard no-no for anyone non-technical: the graphical login did not work until I manually switched to the text terminal and installed the latest NVidia driver (Titan V).

And even now one of my screens does not wake up until I toggle it on/off.

And no freeform per-screen DPI.

Post reply on HN