Live data from Hacker News

Tax dialysis: How Vanguard avoids paying realised gains tax on their mutual fund

bloomberg.com

21–23 of 23 posts

Re: Tax dialysis: How Vanguard avoids paying realised gains tax on their mutual fund

#21
While we’re on the topic, I’ve never understood how Berkshire Hathaway isn’t triple taxed.

For example they own gieco. Say gieco makes a profit. Gieco pays a corporate tax on that profit. Then they send the money to the parent company, brk. Brk now pays corporate tax (and dividend tax?) on that same money?

Re: Tax dialysis: How Vanguard avoids paying realised gains tax on their mutual fund

#22
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the case of mutual funds, the individual investors are all subject to capital gains (or losses) whenever the fund sells any shares. Even if the investor hasn’t divested any money from the fund. This loophole now results in investors only being subject to taxation when they actually sell their stake in the fund. IE the same way as how ETFs are designed to work. Alternatives result in double taxation, which means it…

> This loophole now results in investors only being subject to taxation when they actually sell their stake in the fund. IE the same way as how ETFs are designed to work. Your phrasing is slightly misleading. The only reason under tax law that EFTs are taxed this way is because EFTs have always used this same tax dodge. So it's not as if Vanguard has patented (and used) a legal loophole for getting EFT tax treatment…

Not really a tax dodge its the way investment trusts have worked for over a hundred years - and they helped build America :-)

Re: Tax dialysis: How Vanguard avoids paying realised gains tax on their mutual fund

#23
post #11

> My only complaint is that Vanguard has patented this method, so nobody else can immunize a mutual fund from taxes by bolting on an ETF What the...? How is that possible, patenting a tax loophole ?!

It appears they are using an algorithmic process to perform the heartbeat trading, and they are patentable[0] as long as they are not illegal. Tax loopholes are not illegal but very unethical, I think the policy makers share equal if not more blame for this. [0] https://www.quora.com/Is-it-possible-to-patent-an-algorithm

The "policy-makers" are the people exploiting the loopholes. They are the same people.
Post reply on HN