Live data from Hacker News

Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

nytimes.com

41–50 of 172 posts

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#41
post #10

I wonder if the current political reputation of USA and Trump will play into Assange dodging extradition.

That doesn't really bear on the independence of the US courts which would be the main issue, and they have recently proved themselves quite independent of an often opposed to the will of the president and political interference.

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#42
post #38

> Around two dozen activists gathered outside the court to protest against his potential extradition, waving signs that read “Free Julian Assange” and “Is this all just about shutting us all up?” as they demanded his release. That's not a very impressive show-up. I had hoped he would get more support than a few dozen people.

It's not like this has been getting much traction in the media anyway

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#43
post #33
post #3

Keep in mind all the crimes by US officials that Assange revealed. In my view many of those crimes committed by officials are treason, yet all have been swept under the rug.

None of the things he revealed can be classified as treason. War crimes maybe, treason no way. I also wonder why he never revealed any of Russia's alleged crimes in Ukraine or Syria. Just a thought.

Did he have access to data about "Russia's alleged crimes in Ukraine or Syria"?

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#45
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Assange is accused of a crime. Should he be forgiven because some other people are also accused of crimes?

In this case there's a bit of a conflict of interest, considering that he was the one who showed that the government accusing him committed crimes

That's why the judiciary and the executive are independent of each other.

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#46
post #20

I guess this news gives Assange a valid reason for his bail-jumping. He was suspected of raping in Sweden. That was what he was bail-jumping for. But the real reason is the threat of his extradition to US for... what? revealing the war crime of the US? That shall never be a crime. War crime shall not be hidden. US shall be punished for obstructing the information of war crime.

He ran to the UK... that's not the place you go if you're fleeing the long arm of the US.

Assange long ago lost any credibility as far as I'm concerned. I think his statements are about crafting his own public narrative than really revealing any of his motivations / actual choices. Wikileaks repeatedly claimed they would release X information, and then simply didn't and wouldn't say a word. I'm not sure if they still have a Facebook page but if you even asked about past claims the question would be quickly removed.

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#47
post #3

Keep in mind all the crimes by US officials that Assange revealed. In my view many of those crimes committed by officials are treason, yet all have been swept under the rug.

Which of his crimes looks like treason? He didn’t hack anything, his only “crime” is providing a publishing outlet. (And yes, Assange is highly biased and anti-American, which is not good, but publishing leaks shouldn’t be a crime.)

It's funny to label someone anti-american, when all they've done is expose america's crimes and ways of manipulating the rest of the world. Makes you think what does being pro-america mean.

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#48
post #20

I guess this news gives Assange a valid reason for his bail-jumping. He was suspected of raping in Sweden. That was what he was bail-jumping for. But the real reason is the threat of his extradition to US for... what? revealing the war crime of the US? That shall never be a crime. War crime shall not be hidden. US shall be punished for obstructing the information of war crime.

Wouldn't he have been safer in Sweden than in the UK? If I were to bet on who were more likely to suck up to the Americans of the two, my money would be on the Brits.

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#49
post #20

I guess this news gives Assange a valid reason for his bail-jumping. He was suspected of raping in Sweden. That was what he was bail-jumping for. But the real reason is the threat of his extradition to US for... what? revealing the war crime of the US? That shall never be a crime. War crime shall not be hidden. US shall be punished for obstructing the information of war crime.

> for... what? revealing the war crime of the US?

They're trying to get him for being an accomplice to specific computer crimes related to the acquisition of that information. Of course, the motivation is retribution for embarrassing the government.

Re: Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing

#50
post #20

I guess this news gives Assange a valid reason for his bail-jumping. He was suspected of raping in Sweden. That was what he was bail-jumping for. But the real reason is the threat of his extradition to US for... what? revealing the war crime of the US? That shall never be a crime. War crime shall not be hidden. US shall be punished for obstructing the information of war crime.

Recall that he originally fled Sweden to the UK. That is not the actions of a man who fears extradition to the US. That's the exact opposite course of action any sane person would take.
Post reply on HN