Live data from Hacker News

Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

bbc.com

21–30 of 61 posts

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#21

That's sad. In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties. A single strong leader at the top is needed, someone with courage and a strong resolve, and a cle…

Send better trolls.

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#22

That's sad. In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties. A single strong leader at the top is needed, someone with courage and a strong resolve, and a cle…

Sure, a benevolent, supremely intelligent and incorruptible dictator would be the best leader for any country.

But governments should be about stability, resilience and steady progress, and not optimizing for superb efficiency at the cost of being extremely unstable.

Edit: Also to be clear, the dictator in question would be a fairy tale person. As such we could add a requirement for dragons, that would be cool.

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#23

That's sad. In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties. A single strong leader at the top is needed, someone with courage and a strong resolve, and a cle…

>In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties.

Nearly every extant democracy, even those with constitutional monarchs, is a strong counterpoint to your claim.

>It may be said that "absolute power corrupts absolutely" but not if the man believes in and is led by absolute truth

The problem with the 'philosopher king' is that it's a Platonic ideal, and never really present in reality.

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#24

That's sad. In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties. A single strong leader at the top is needed, someone with courage and a strong resolve, and a cle…

China had that approach. If they had a good emperor, it worked reasonably well (at least in terms of national stability). But they never solved the "bad emperor" problem.

And that's still the problem. If you get the one perfect person - and if they remain the perfect person - then your approach works. But people who are good enough, and will remain good enough, are in really short supply, so the odds are stacked against your approach.

And if you have a bad person, an unwise person, a selfish person, or a lazy person, your approach is catastrophic. So the rest of us don't want to go there...

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#25
Truly the end of an era. Akihito became emperor in 1989. At that time it seemed humanity was finally ready to put great power conflicts in the past. Akihito represented a generation that had experienced the horrors of WWII as children and saw the need to make sure that never happened again.

Now as Akihito abdicates, the whispers of great power conflicts are starting again. Old alliances and coalitions that have kept the peace for 70 years are being questioned. Nationalism is rising throughout the world. I hope the new Emperor’s reign will be just as peaceful as his father’s, but I am pessimistic.

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#26

That's sad. In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties. A single strong leader at the top is needed, someone with courage and a strong resolve, and a cle…

Sure, a benevolent, supremely intelligent and incorruptible dictator would be the best leader for any country. But governments should be about stability, resilience and steady progress, and not optimizing for superb efficiency at the cost of being extremely unstable. Edit: Also to be clear, the dictator in question would be a fairy tale person. As such we could add a requirement for dragons, that would be cool.

I would be totally cool pledging my allegiance to a dragon lord. Until then, all these politicians can jump in a lake.

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#27

That's sad. In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties. A single strong leader at the top is needed, someone with courage and a strong resolve, and a cle…

The trouble is that even a wise and capable ruler sometimes picks a terrible successor. The most obvious example is the succession of Commodus after Aurelius —- Marcus was and is a widely read philosopher and admired leader, but his idiot son drove Rome into the ground.

The Yamato dynasty in Japan is the longest-lived political system on record, period. Historically, many emperors left governing to their subordinates; in some cases, there were even civil wars, but their longevity suggests an advantage to this approach.

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#28

That's sad. In my observation of governments, if they do not have a single strong leader at the very top who answers to no one but serves everyone, then those who do govern will be so scattered in their plans and opinions that the government will be rendered almost completely ineffective at fulfilling its primary duties. A single strong leader at the top is needed, someone with courage and a strong resolve, and a cle…

> King Louis of France

Which one? Because there's 17 of them. (I count 17 kings of France named Louis, since Louis 17 never reigned or anything)

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#29
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like a pretty good gig. How do I apply?

I mean he basically begged to be fired, so it’s probably not all that much fun. They sacrifice any semblance of normalcy and have an endless calendar of ceremonies and events. Emperor Akihito acquitted himself pretty well in the job, and most people in Japan seem to be either indifferent to the royals or appreciate their focus on peace and calm and continuity. They’re a pretty boring royal family, which means they’re…

One of the particular difficulties of the Japanese royal family is you have the ultra-nationalists who never really got over Japan's loss in WW2 and the resulting changes to the Japanese royal nature, but the royalty has. You end up with a situation where the emperor indicates that he wants the nature of the royal family to change slightly, but the biggest supporters of royalty don't want to listen to him.

This is rather different compared to the constitutional monarchies that are common in Europe: it's hard to imagine any major political party (even the hard-right parties) arguing against the monarch if the monarch is suggesting a more liberal position.

Re: Emperor Akihito: Japanese monarch declares historic abdication

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like a pretty good gig. How do I apply?

Hey thanks for your interest but right now we're looking for people with 800+ years in lineage and 8 years of WebAssembly experience.

How am I going to get to be a senior-level monarch if I can't get some experience?
Post reply on HN