Live data from Hacker News

How China is replacing America as Asia’s military titan

reuters.com

1–10 of 70 posts

Re: How China is replacing America as Asia’s military titan

#3
post #2

It is long overdue. China has 1.3B people and the second largest economy in the world. It is righteous for them to be Asia's military titan.

I am not sure whether anyone being a military titan can be defined as "righteous", but its definitely been something that was going to happen sooner rather than later.

Re: How China is replacing America as Asia’s military titan

#4
post #2

It is long overdue. China has 1.3B people and the second largest economy in the world. It is righteous for them to be Asia's military titan.

Yes just as it was righteous for Japan to assert itself over all of Asia.

No it's isn't. And this will not be good for the world. The reason being that being a sleeping friendly giant is much better for your long term survival than being an asshole looking to assert themselves. Especially in a world in which other people exist to challenge you, and you are challenging them. Because then they will conspire against you and try to wear you down.

The only reason the US has been able to get away with being the world's asshole since WWII is that it has not really had any real competition in that field. It's just been going around fucking over countries that could not defend themselves. We don't need leaders like these in the world. We need leaders that focus on commerce and leave everything else to individuals and smaller groups to decide.

Also the Communist Party of China is in no way representative of the people of China. You need democracy for that. These are basically fascist totalitarians that have succeeded. And sure the Chinese may be behind them right now, but these sort of regimes sooner or later start causing misery of their own people. Let's see how it is before that happens.

Re: How China is replacing America as Asia’s military titan

#7
post #4
post #2

It is long overdue. China has 1.3B people and the second largest economy in the world. It is righteous for them to be Asia's military titan.

Yes just as it was righteous for Japan to assert itself over all of Asia. No it's isn't. And this will not be good for the world. The reason being that being a sleeping friendly giant is much better for your long term survival than being an asshole looking to assert themselves. Especially in a world in which other people exist to challenge you, and you are challenging them. Because then they will conspire against you…

Let's be clear. Being the world's military titan is not a desirable job. Someone has to fend off the Somali pirates, but it's not glamorous and everyone benefits equally from it (as in not just the US).

Re: How China is replacing America as Asia’s military titan

#9
post #2

It is long overdue. China has 1.3B people and the second largest economy in the world. It is righteous for them to be Asia's military titan.

I wonder if you meant 'right' like 'appropriate'? Clearly you could not have meant 'righteous' since it does mean something else in English.
Post reply on HN