Live data from Hacker News

Has Google been humbled?

colabopad.blogspot.com

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#11
Google is a software monopoly at this point anyway. they wont go away even if you want them to.. they run your phone now!

Google is the executor of current internet innovation. although i use all their products because they are free and work. So i guess I'm the hypocrite

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#12

I can't tell if this is a joke or not. I know the Hacker News hivemind is hate Google / love Apple, but this is ridiculous. You want to know what Google has released to great success in the past five years? Here you go: Google Chat Google Docs Google Calendar Google Checkout YouTube Android Google Chrome Google Voice Google TV Granted a few of these are acquisitions, but I'm leaving out a ton of tiny projects and the…

Only three things on the list I'd call great success, and two of them are acquisitions: Youtube and Android, third was build on the great work of others—Chrome.

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#13

Could it be Google was as surprised as everyone else about Groupon's revenues? During the rumors about Google's offer of $2 billion and then later $5 or $6 billion everyone was reporting Groupon at $500 million per year. After the deal was rejected people are reporting $2 _billion_ per year instead. As far as innovation from their acquisitions, Google still has Dodgeball. Even without Dennis Crowley they must own som…

top line revenue vs. bottom line income (i.e. minus expenses, which include payouts to the merchants...)

I'd rather generally own a business making $5b/yr in profit on $10b/yr in revenue, vs. $0b/yr in profit on $30b/yr in revenue.

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#14

yes they have definitely become irrelevant and lack even a minor understanding about the value of technology what with the second most popular smartphone os, a video site with a paltry billion page views per day and the second most popular website. man I wanna be considered irrelevant too

Don't forget their dull and drab email with its pointless tags and terrible filtering options.

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#15
post #3

What is Google doing at the moment? Chrome and Android are under development, but I can't really see anything else on the horizon. Search results now have a somewhat annoying hover preview, but I am wondering what else is going on over there.

GoogleTV was just released. If it succeeds at doing for television what Android did for phone, it's kind of a big deal.

I got Logitech Revue (GoogleTV) a week ago through the Google developer program and I've been playing with it, trying to imagine how this is all going to fit together. It's a bit bleeding-edge now but it could easily take off if they can just push out enough updates and introduce the App Store to it.

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#16

I can't tell if this is a joke or not. I know the Hacker News hivemind is hate Google / love Apple, but this is ridiculous. You want to know what Google has released to great success in the past five years? Here you go: Google Chat Google Docs Google Calendar Google Checkout YouTube Android Google Chrome Google Voice Google TV Granted a few of these are acquisitions, but I'm leaving out a ton of tiny projects and the…

Only three things on the list I'd call great success, and two of them are acquisitions: Youtube and Android, third was build on the great work of others—Chrome.

The iPod was largely built on contracted work and Safari/Webkit was built off KHTML. I don't get this whole "if not built 100% in-house, it doesn't count" meme. You might have a point about YouTube being an acquisition, but giving credit to anyone but Google for Android and Chrome's (or Apple for the iPod and Safari's) success seems like intentionally looking for loopholes instead of acknowledging their work.

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#17

I can't tell if this is a joke or not. I know the Hacker News hivemind is hate Google / love Apple, but this is ridiculous. You want to know what Google has released to great success in the past five years? Here you go: Google Chat Google Docs Google Calendar Google Checkout YouTube Android Google Chrome Google Voice Google TV Granted a few of these are acquisitions, but I'm leaving out a ton of tiny projects and the…

you are missing the point. the article was only criticizing hiring process at google.

when google makes an acquisition, they'll also gain people who built that technology/product too. these people usually went through completely different hiring process and it's entirely possible that early employees who made let's say youtube, would probably never make it through those tricky interview questions at google...

heck, most startup founders here wouldn't make it into google through their standard interview process. then google ends up buying their companies for millions. go figure.

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#18
Google has definitely been humbled by Twitter, Groupon, Facebook, etc. That said, they're still awesomely successful and useful. The point of the post, though, is about how Google is becoming less relevant/useful and I couldn't disagree more.

Pewpewarrows listed technologies. These are the ones I gladly depend and use at least once per week on:

Search

Gmail (6+ accounts)

Docs

Cal

Contacts

Tasks

Picasa

Custom Search

Reader

Android

Chrome

Ad Manager (DFP)

Adwords

Analytics

Website Optimizer

Python (a bit of a stretch, but I use it because Google does...)

My life is just a lot better because of these bits of technology. Seriously. Lots better. So bummer about Groupon, but Google's rockin and super relevant.

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#19

I can't tell if this is a joke or not. I know the Hacker News hivemind is hate Google / love Apple, but this is ridiculous. You want to know what Google has released to great success in the past five years? Here you go: Google Chat Google Docs Google Calendar Google Checkout YouTube Android Google Chrome Google Voice Google TV Granted a few of these are acquisitions, but I'm leaving out a ton of tiny projects and the…

Chat: uhhh, really?

Docs: fear of Microsoft

Calendar: uhhh, really?

Checkout: sucks

Youtube: Acq.

Android: Acq. but still sucks

Chrome: Awesome product.

Voice: haven't heard of it, and that's saying something.

TV: Also haven't heard of it (enough).

But, you left out one major thing, and what I think will be their saving grace (besides the obvious other 2):

Google App Engine: Getting Much Better!

Re: Has Google been humbled?

#20
post #2

I recently switched to Windows Live. Google sites is a joke. I can make a call with my computer using Google Voice but only through gMail. I can't use the Chrome Google Voice extension to do this. Things like this have made me give up on the Google.

Are you saying you switched to the MSFT competitor to Sites (if such a thing exists)? If so, what does it do better than Sites?

Disclaimer: I have a friend on the Sites team...if you could make your comment constructive I'd be willing to pass it along.

Post reply on HN