Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
hncynic.leod.org
Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
1–10 of 86 posts
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#2obligatory test:
Generate hacker news comments from titles
hncynic 1 minute ago
I thought it was going to be more like /. but I'm confused. Can you add some sort of comment link to /, which is something I could have easily navigated, like /. and /. would be great.
hncynic 1 minute ago
Nice, but I wonder why you would want to do the same with comments on the same page. If you're not really getting it, why make a single sentence and the title different?
hncynic 1 minute ago
How about adding a "Downvote" to the title? For example, "Hackernews: The best comment in the world: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=635686
"What I like about the HN thread, which is that I don't have to post links here to get upvotes on comments from hacker-news posts"
I just wanted a way to filter out the "Ask" from your comments so you could add new comments, and then maybe change the URL to "Show HN" to the "About the Hacker News thread" link.
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#3I typed in “hacker news comment generator” and was disappointed to not find “I could build this in a weekend” as one of the outputs
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#4This is really fantastic! How do you generate these kind of comments?
I have the same question but without the title. Maybe I can generate the "Ask HN: Hacker News Comments" link from titles by tagging it by topic.
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#5It would be useful to see the comments and get an idea of the quality of each title. This site does a good job of conveying what is good enough while still providing a summary of the contents and submitting an opinion.
How do you get your comment title into the list?
You can just use a few of the existing ones: http://hn.algolia.com/hacker
It's not perfect, but it works fine
(all three comment above generated by OP's site)
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#6The previous thread had some interesting example outputs:
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#7just entered "seo test" and the garbage out was 100% spot on! congrats!
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#8Nice, and I like it too -- but it lacks the comments that are so useful for me. I've found a ton of good ideas to use on sites that I've just bought.
I've had a lot of fun making a script similar to this that would convert your site to a commenting system. Thoughts?
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#9Would be handy if it could generate the article too.
Re: Generate Hacker News Comments from Titles
#10thiscommentdoesnotexist.com