Live data from Hacker News

Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

glamourmagazine.co.uk

11–20 of 79 posts

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#11
I'd rather see this so called "toxic positivity" than people patting each other on the back and reinforcing their depression and mental health issues as though it were an identity or something to form a community around.

It sounds harsh, but there are so many counter productive behaviors people engage in while meaning well with regard to mental health issues on social media. One I see often is that people are effectively embracing catastrophizing as some sort of rebellious act of defiant need for other people to acknowledge their distorted view of reality.

Don't get me wrong either. I'm not looking at this from an outsider perspective. I've been there. I've been dealing with on and off depression and anxiety for the past several years. I've managed to claw myself out of it, but am able to accept that how I acted while there was not healthy for me. I have to take full responsibility for my behaviors and the bridges I've burnt.

All that being said, this article reads like someone waist deep in the throes of "Acknowledge my depressed reality!"

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#12

...written by Glamour magazine. Perhaps one of the greatest sinners in this regard actively profiting from content that leads to covetousness, jealousy, etc. leading to mental health issues and what not.

I had this thought too, but hey, however the message gets out I'm glad it does. If we spit in the faces of those people, they'll just put up walls and go back to the old ways. I prefer, "welcome friend, today is a new day"

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#13
This article seems more related to social media, but my experience with toxic positivity at some former workplaces took the form of "Our startup is the best! We're so much better than all our competitors. Everything they do is wrong, and we do everything better!", which is a fine attitude to have in general, until its objectively not true, and I'm afraid to even say anything for fear of being a "hater".

A "Salesperson" attitude is great when talking to the public or customers, but when your employees hear one thing from you and see the opposite happening, it doesn't exactly lend you credibility.

Fortunately, where I work now the leadership is much more objectively-minded. It probably helps we're building enterprise products and not pushing social-media hype.

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#14

...written by Glamour magazine. Perhaps one of the greatest sinners in this regard actively profiting from content that leads to covetousness, jealousy, etc. leading to mental health issues and what not.

Granted, it would have been powerful if the author had called out (or was allowed to call out) Glamour's hypocrisy on this matter, but I think the fact that they're talking about the topic at all is a step in the right direction.

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#15
post #2

I'm constantly having to remind my wife that she's a good mother. She keeps seeing all the posts on Facebook from her groups about how some woman made dinner, built a diorama and made enough to buy a new purse from her side business all in one day! And she thinks she's a slacker because "all" she can do is feed the kids and read them a story. I have to keep telling her that she's only seeing the highlight reel of tho…

Soon after our first was born my wife asked her moms group: 'is four in the afternoon too early to have a beer?'. They answered: 'Oh, no, we've discussed it extensively and three o'clock is fine.'

Nothing wrong with being an ambitious mom but you need to pick the right support group and it's probably not instagram.

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#16
The next article this website wants me to read is "Literally everyone is wearing this Mango suit on social media RN". I actually don't know much about this particular magazine, but one wishes that as an organization they would have more self-awareness about the mixed messages they send.

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#17
post #2

I'm constantly having to remind my wife that she's a good mother. She keeps seeing all the posts on Facebook from her groups about how some woman made dinner, built a diorama and made enough to buy a new purse from her side business all in one day! And she thinks she's a slacker because "all" she can do is feed the kids and read them a story. I have to keep telling her that she's only seeing the highlight reel of tho…

i totally commiserate with what you describe.

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#18
On a personal note, I find occasional honest negativity to be endearing, refreshing, and stress-relieving. Back when I had the good fortune to visit Ireland, I went to comedy clubs to get a feel for local culture. I stumbled upon this hilarious musical comedian who sang a song [1] about how hard life is, yet no one talks about it.

It's easy to overdo it, though. Negative people are draining.

[1] https://youtu.be/S59FMm2wMUk

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#19
post #5

There is science to suggest that negative talk can influence your mental health in deleterious ways. Words do create a reality to some extent, great or small. There is no science (at least none that I know of) that indicates that someone telling you this fact helps you get out of this mode of being. Therein lies the rub.

Mind over matter is definitely a thing, but where it becomes toxic is if you choose to ignore problems in order to keep the good vibes going, and could lead to a worse outcome than if you kept an objective mind. Reality distortion fields only work if they actually influence reality, and not just your perception of it.

With that said, I have a friend who is in a depression rut. He hates his job but believes any other job will be just as bad (he's definitely wrong), and seems to refuse to take steps to improve his situation, because his negativity keeps him from taking action.

So ultimately its just a balance.

Re: Social media is spreading 'toxic positivity'

#20
I wonder if this forced positivity thing isn’t an American thing only (which is creeping its way through to Europe, I agree). For once I’m happy (no pun intended) that I grew up and still live in Eastern Europe where you can really tell how things are and how you feel about them without having to worry about what other people might think about your thinking.
Post reply on HN