Live data from Hacker News

I write fake online reviews

bbc.co.uk

21–30 of 91 posts

Re: I write fake online reviews

#21
I only write reviews when my experience is on either extreme. Expectations exceeded or the disappointment is too much to ignore.

It's kind of like work, innit? Who is going to pat your back when you arrive and leave on time and get your work done? No one. Why should they? It's your job.

Go above and beyond or go in the opposite direction and slack off and you deserve all the feedback coming your way.

Re: I write fake online reviews

#22

The title should be "Why bbc reads Hacker News comments to get ideas for its next article." I could swear I just read a discussion on HN (just hours ago) in response to an article about Amazon getting flooded with fake reviews. Some suggested how they write fake reviews for money and how one could monetize fake reviews. Then here comes this BBC article. Coincidence. I think not.

The recent article posted here was actually a link to the previous BBC article:

https://www.bbc.com/news/business-47941181

For reference the discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19669898

Re: I write fake online reviews

#24

The title should be "Why bbc reads Hacker News comments to get ideas for its next article." I could swear I just read a discussion on HN (just hours ago) in response to an article about Amazon getting flooded with fake reviews. Some suggested how they write fake reviews for money and how one could monetize fake reviews. Then here comes this BBC article. Coincidence. I think not.

The recent article posted here was actually a link to the previous BBC article: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-47941181 For reference the discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19669898

Well I guess its not all that bad if, at least, the article is following up on points of interests collected from responses to a former article.

Re: I write fake online reviews

#25
post #3

I tend to ignore good reviews and rely on bad ones mostly to make my decisions. Will also never leave a good review when I'm satisfied, they are indistinguishable from fake ones anyway, I tend to rather just leave bad reviews when I'm not satisfied.

The problem is that bad reviews can be just as fake as good ones, as they could be written by the product's competitors. Also, if a product is popular enough, odds are that even with a great product there'll be a small fraction of people who'll just happen to get a dud, while most of the rest will be satisfied. Because of this, I tend to read both good and bad reviews, and give more weight to the longer reviews that…

I used to do the same, and still sometimes do for bigger investments like good headphones. Other than that i only use Amazon for things im knowledgeable about. For other things where I'm not sure about quality etc and i would have to rely on reviews to make an informed decision i usually don't bother anymore and source it from local brick and mortar stores, either go in person or use their online store.

Blows my mind how amazon is not paying more attention to this issue, i used to get almost everything on amazon - not so much anymore.

Re: I write fake online reviews

#26
post #2

Positive reviews are not very informative. What I find more informative is bad reviews that get an answer from the seller/company. I guess these interactions will be faked in the next iteration of reviewogenesis.

which is why saas review sites like TrustRadius, G2Cros, etc are useless. Almost every single product has at least a 4/5 rating and there are hardly any negative reviews. Which tells me only people who had a paid incentive left a review. Useless!

Re: I write fake online reviews

#27
post #3

I tend to ignore good reviews and rely on bad ones mostly to make my decisions. Will also never leave a good review when I'm satisfied, they are indistinguishable from fake ones anyway, I tend to rather just leave bad reviews when I'm not satisfied.

Let's face it, reviews are useless. Even when they come from professional product critics. Those critics can be compromised (bribed) by big business just the same. A good example of this were reviews for 'Star Wars: The Last Jedi'; most reviews either against and in favor of that movie, by critic or causal viewer, were either fake or compromised.

Re: I write fake online reviews

#28
I write no reviews at all. Also, take no customer service surveys. Why provide free services to billionaires?

Let amazon hire a product review staff. Let Verizon supervisors monitor the quality of the phone staff. Let uber hire secret shoppers.

These companies are all exploiting your good will to enrich themselves.

Re: I write fake online reviews

#29
post #3

I tend to ignore good reviews and rely on bad ones mostly to make my decisions. Will also never leave a good review when I'm satisfied, they are indistinguishable from fake ones anyway, I tend to rather just leave bad reviews when I'm not satisfied.

Let's face it, reviews are useless. Even when they come from professional product critics. Those critics can be compromised (bribed) by big business just the same. A good example of this were reviews for 'Star Wars: The Last Jedi'; most reviews either against and in favor of that movie, by critic or causal viewer, were either fake or compromised.

It's easy to declare that reviews are useless. So how do you choose products then?
Post reply on HN