Live data from Hacker News

I miss Facebook

cfenollosa.com

41–50 of 123 posts

Re: I miss Facebook

#41

My solution was to create a fake account with a fake name on FB, never download the app to my phone, never share my phone number, never upload any contacts, never use a real picture, and only add close friends who know who the fake profile is. Makes me pretty much impossible to look up on the system, I value my privacy and not being listed is important to me. This gives me the best of both worlds. I can join all the…

[deleted]

Re: I miss Facebook

#42

I am not sure the "niche" Facebook used to fill even exists anymore. The social landscape has changed for the worse. People no longer want to connect with friends, they want to show off how better/popular/wealthier they think they are. Even if someone relaunched that era's Facebook without all the crap I wouldn't be surprised if today's society still manages to make it toxic.

> The social landscape has changed for the worse. People no longer want to connect with friends, they want to show off how better/popular/wealthier they think they are.

It is the gamification factor. People is optimizing their behavior to get more likes not to get better connected.

"Given the opportunity, players will optimize the fun out of a game" summarizes quite well the situation.

Re: I miss Facebook

#43
post #13

I miss IRC, for a lot of the same reasons the author misses Facebook. Being above 35 like the author, I think it’s more the fact that people just aren’t chatty anymore. It’s anecdotal of course, but if I look at myself, I’m really not that chatty anymore either. I too used to have late night chats about random stupid things, but right now, I can even remember when I last saw 3AM unless it was to feed a baby or clean…

I am in the exact same spot. Whenever I do get the chance to go back to gaming/IRC I tend to feel quite bad about it (it's strongly affiliated with being lonely). So what to do now, it doesn't make it easier that the amount of freedom without responsibilities is quite low and tend to show up spontaneously. As it should be when you have kids.

It's painful to let go of those memories and accept that life has probably changed permanently, and with that what kind of activity that fits best.

Re: I miss Facebook

#44
IMO Facebook has three useful features left: the personal rolodex, event planning, and groups. I truly think that a large number of users would migrate over if someone replicated those three. No large info collection on your profile, no wall or posts, just a friend/messaging option, the ability to create events, and to organize into groups made by users to make posts there only, not in public. You know, to actually make and support communities that would actual exist in physical space.

With the troubles of Facebook and the alternatives, many just don't use Facebook anymore, even if those features aren't broken. If it's a fresh service with no ties to Facebook, I think you'd see something interesting.

Re: I miss Facebook

#46
post #44

IMO Facebook has three useful features left: the personal rolodex, event planning, and groups. I truly think that a large number of users would migrate over if someone replicated those three. No large info collection on your profile, no wall or posts, just a friend/messaging option, the ability to create events, and to organize into groups made by users to make posts there only, not in public. You know, to actually m…

Groups is really the only thing I use it for anymore. The rest of its 'features' have become more and more useless.

Re: I miss Facebook

#47
post #42

I am not sure the "niche" Facebook used to fill even exists anymore. The social landscape has changed for the worse. People no longer want to connect with friends, they want to show off how better/popular/wealthier they think they are. Even if someone relaunched that era's Facebook without all the crap I wouldn't be surprised if today's society still manages to make it toxic.

> The social landscape has changed for the worse. People no longer want to connect with friends, they want to show off how better/popular/wealthier they think they are. It is the gamification factor. People is optimizing their behavior to get more likes not to get better connected. "Given the opportunity, players will optimize the fun out of a game" summarizes quite well the situation.

So we need to remove likes from Facebook? It definitely was a different place prior to the feature.

Re: I miss Facebook

#48
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is this really true or is this a case of "get off my lawn" that seems to naturally come with getting older? People have always behaved that way as far as I know, just by different mediums. Going to the symphony is one of my favorite things and people throw me dirty looks because I don't wear a suit and gaudy jewelry/accessories there; I doubt that's new or a result of social media.

So you just turn up in jeans/t-shirt to listen to some Rachmaninoff?

You don't? I generally wear long sleeves, but I prefer to be comfortable at concerts.

Re: I miss Facebook

#49
post #44

IMO Facebook has three useful features left: the personal rolodex, event planning, and groups. I truly think that a large number of users would migrate over if someone replicated those three. No large info collection on your profile, no wall or posts, just a friend/messaging option, the ability to create events, and to organize into groups made by users to make posts there only, not in public. You know, to actually m…

Those were the same three features that were a core part of thefacebook before they introduced the News Feed. If it was the same site that it was in 2005, but with more people, I'd still be using it. But now, it's mainly a machine that turns other people's content into dollars.

Re: I miss Facebook

#50
post #2

Back when Facebook changed to the Newsfeed algorithm I knew it wasn't good and I didnt like it. In retrospect its definently when it all started going downhill for me as a user of the platform. Now, I haven't posted anything in 3 years....

Exactly this. It used to be a real-time showcase of what my friends and family were up to. Great to keep tabs on everyone I care about lives. Now it's just ads and the same few posters. I don't even read the newsfeed at all any more. I go directly to a few people's pages to see updates on a few close friends, nieces and nephews and that's it.
Post reply on HN