Live data from Hacker News

Matrix.org hacked

web.archive.org

31–40 of 277 posts

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#31
The hacker seems nice:

“Anyways, that's all for now. I hope this series of issues has given you some good ideas for how to prevent this level of compromise in the future. Security doesn't work retroactively, but I believe in you and I think you'll come back from this even stronger than before.

Or at least, I hope so -- My own information is in this user table.”

https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix.org/issues/365

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#32
post #2

For a bit of context: Matrix.org infrastructure has been hacked a second time in 24h, after restoring everything they went down again, story developing here: https://twitter.com/matrixdotorg/status/1116304867683905537

I am highly skeptical when people taking about "rebuilding [the whole] infrastructure" in a few hours. Even more so when restoring all data from breached systems and before a thorough incident analysis. Show me the org which can just pull that off.

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#33
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The hacker is now doing a post-mortem in the GitHub issues of the project: https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix.org/issues

This is gold... > I noticed in your blog post that you were talking about doing a postmortem and steps you need to take. As someone who is intimately familiar with your entire infrastructure, I thought I could help you out. > There I was, just going about my business, looking for ways I could get higher levels of access and explore your network more, when I stumbled across GPG keys that were used for signing your deb…

Why would they do this? It's pure negligence. I don't even sign anything important and still worry about my keys.

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#34
post #4

Everything gets hacked, period. They have to remove this from there slogan, "An open standard for decentralised secure communication."

Really ? That's a bold claim. Can this string be hacked ? $6$WqQvgIwr$/BA/19FRJZf.z4buUwX5Sbls07ovv/lVZJ3V2En7VgTR4Skdpz98hFNuq3VX4nIaiSDKObO9jKbkPb5tdt7zY1

I guess the point is that you cannot protect anything from the future if you don't just destroy it completely.

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#35
post #26
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The hacker is now doing a post-mortem in the GitHub issues of the project: https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix.org/issues

hilarious...

I can only think of the despair I would be in if I was in Aragorn's shoes

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#36
post #32
post #2

For a bit of context: Matrix.org infrastructure has been hacked a second time in 24h, after restoring everything they went down again, story developing here: https://twitter.com/matrixdotorg/status/1116304867683905537

I am highly skeptical when people taking about "rebuilding [the whole] infrastructure" in a few hours. Even more so when restoring all data from breached systems and before a thorough incident analysis. Show me the org which can just pull that off.

It's quite common in enterprise to have a RTO of a few hours, and RPO of a few minutes, even for infrastructure with terrabytes of data. Of course, many moneys are paid for being able to do that.

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#37
I can see a lot of people trashing on Matrix.org or the "hacker" themselves (the hacker opened a series of issues, detailing how he managed to get in - https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix.org/issues/created_by/m...). However everyone seems to be missing the point - matrix seems like a pretty cool and open project. And someone taking over their infrastructure in such an open way is also great for the community. Even though a little dubious on the legal side of things, I believe it's great it was approached with transparency and a dose of humor.

Some might argue that this is harmful to matrix as a product and as a brand. But as long as there was no actual harm done and they react appropriately by taking infrastructure security seriously, it could play out well in the end for them. This whole ordeal could end up actually increase trust in the project, if they take swift steps to ensure that something like this does not happen again.

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#38

The hacker seems nice: “Anyways, that's all for now. I hope this series of issues has given you some good ideas for how to prevent this level of compromise in the future. Security doesn't work retroactively, but I believe in you and I think you'll come back from this even stronger than before. Or at least, I hope so -- My own information is in this user table.” https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix.org/issues/365

Hopefully, but it could be just posturing.

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#39
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The hacker is now doing a post-mortem in the GitHub issues of the project: https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix.org/issues

This is gold... > I noticed in your blog post that you were talking about doing a postmortem and steps you need to take. As someone who is intimately familiar with your entire infrastructure, I thought I could help you out. > There I was, just going about my business, looking for ways I could get higher levels of access and explore your network more, when I stumbled across GPG keys that were used for signing your deb…

Another gem:

RRREEEEEEEE> I noticed you missed a doctype in your html page. In order for web browsers to know what type of html to render you should include a doctype. Thanks!

matrixnotorg> @RRREEEEEEEE Thank you, I will consider that for the next release

Edit: it got deleted

But see also: https://github.com/matrixnotorg/matrixnotorg.github.io/pull/...

Re: Matrix.org hacked

#40
I'm probably really out of the loop, but what is matrix.org? Looks like an open source slack clone? Why do they have >5 million user accounts? Is that everybody who uses that chat tool?
Post reply on HN