Live data from Hacker News

Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

zdnet.com

11–20 of 75 posts

Re: Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

#11
post #3

Is there a summary of the algorithms he used anywhere? I don't see how it was the language that won the competition, rather than the code he wrote in it.

Looks like alpha beta with a good evaluation function, move ordering, and a changing depth parameter (not sure about this one, though).

Ah, thanks. Nothing that couldn't be implemented in a number of languages, then...

Re: Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

#14

A better title: "3 Time Winner of Computer Games Olympiad Wins Yet Another Contest".

Can't believe this Reddit quality comment is getting any upvotes. Google AI Challenge is "Yet Another Contest"? Though you may not be surprised, he is, http://quotenil.com/Planet-Wars-Post-Mortem.html/.

Re: Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

#15
post #12

Not a bad article, but did you have to make the title a Lisp promotion fest?

This very short article mentions the winner's views, as he sees it, on the suitability of Lisp (used by 0.7% of the contestants, surely interesting) for the job. Half the article never even mentions Lisp. And this amounts to a 'promotion fest'?

Re: Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

#17

Bocsimako is the proof that Lisp is best for AI algorithms Cargo cultism at its finest

Ugh. Cargo cultism? The full quote is:

After seeing Gábor’s performance, many participants commented that they would be taking a new look at the 50 year old language. “Bocsimako is the proof that Lisp is best for AI algorithms,” quipped one player.

one player.

Re: Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

#18

A better title: "3 Time Winner of Computer Games Olympiad Wins Yet Another Contest".

Can't believe this Reddit quality comment is getting any upvotes. Google AI Challenge is "Yet Another Contest"? Though you may not be surprised, he is, http://quotenil.com/Planet-Wars-Post-Mortem.html/ .

The point is that he won because he's a great programmer, not because he used Lisp.

Re: Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

#19

Bocsimako is the proof that Lisp is best for AI algorithms Cargo cultism at its finest

It seems that any positive inclination towards lisp is cargo cultism.

Gabor Melis is a seriously smart guy, and probably would have kicked ass in any language.

That said, I'm going to pull out that phrase next time someone says 'Java/C# is good for Enterprise', or 'C++ is good for video games', or 'C is good for systems programming'.

Cargo cultism indeed.

Re: Lisp developer walks away with Google AI contest

#20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can't believe this Reddit quality comment is getting any upvotes. Google AI Challenge is "Yet Another Contest"? Though you may not be surprised, he is, http://quotenil.com/Planet-Wars-Post-Mortem.html/ .

The point is that he won because he's a great programmer, not because he used Lisp.

It's far from clear which way the causality runs.
Post reply on HN