Live data from Hacker News

Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

futurism.com

11–20 of 55 posts

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#11
post #7

He's about right but it's not really a ground breaking observation.

Agreed, it seems a casual observation that's heading toward universal opinion. Though I agree with the sentiment, I'm not sure Linus carries much authority in speaking about social media.

I'm not so sure a lot of people outside of HN view social media as a disease …

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google+ obviously didn't optimize for engagement, that's why nobody was using it!

In the end I don't think anyone had any idea what Google+ was supposed to be or do, most of all Google themselves.

The main issue was with Google+ was the painfully slow roll out.It killed any chance of viral spread of it it. Same thing happened with Google Wave.

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#14
post #11
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed, it seems a casual observation that's heading toward universal opinion. Though I agree with the sentiment, I'm not sure Linus carries much authority in speaking about social media.

I'm not so sure a lot of people outside of HN view social media as a disease …

Social media gets a lot of bad press in the mainstream media. A lot of people in non-tech circles talk about how to spend less time on Facebook, etc., because they feel it has a negative impact.

Personally, I think it's a shame big social media is such a general disaster, because I've always had a good experience on Facebook and Twitter.

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#15
Not that I disagree with the idea, but aren't these communication tools highlighting or magnifying some basic human behavior traits? I would imagine this happens on a smaller scale through face to face interaction. Is it just the scale of it all that is the issue?

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#16
"Add in anonymity, and it's just disgusting," Torvalds said. "When you don't even put your real name on your garbage (or the garbage you share or like), it really doesn't help."

Except when you see people you knew and respected before social media existed posting and "liking" the same garbage. They either just do not care or they do not know any better.

The lack of anonymity lends itself to the emergence of countless self-promoters who specialise in posting yet more garbage, on a regular basis. The aim of which is often directly or indirectly commercial.

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#17

Of course, Google+ is fine ;)

Google+ obviously didn't optimize for engagement, that's why nobody was using it!

I was using it a ton, precisely because I could choose which groups I joined and how I engaged with it. It was precisely because fancy pants forum software isn't a great platform for algorithm generated engagement spam that I liked it so much.

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#18
I've never been much engaged in FB,TW or Instagram or too many Social platforms. But I still have to disagree with Mr Linus, after all where would we be without the Slashdot effect?

Social media simply accelerates aspects of what we are as humans. Its well known that we humans are genetically more attracted to the negative than the positive for obvious reasons ... and just to be circular: when was the last time something positive Linus said made the news?

So rather than say Social media is an external invading disease i would rather say it is an expression of what makes us human.

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#19

Not that I disagree with the idea, but aren't these communication tools highlighting or magnifying some basic human behavior traits? I would imagine this happens on a smaller scale through face to face interaction. Is it just the scale of it all that is the issue?

My opinion is that, while those traits are there, Facebook et al actively manipulate people to express those traits. Yes, similar things happen in face yo face interactions... with psychopaths. In this way, social media is more like a predator than a disease.

Re: Linus: Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Are “A Disease”

#20
post #18

I've never been much engaged in FB,TW or Instagram or too many Social platforms. But I still have to disagree with Mr Linus, after all where would we be without the Slashdot effect? Social media simply accelerates aspects of what we are as humans. Its well known that we humans are genetically more attracted to the negative than the positive for obvious reasons ... and just to be circular: when was the last time somet…

I have spent some time studying genetics, and really have no idea what you mean by “Its well known that we humans are genetically more attracted to the negative than the positive for obvious reasons”
Post reply on HN