Live data from Hacker News

Google Killing Chrome Extensions with 1 Week Publishing Delays

getpolarized.io

1–10 of 46 posts

Re: Google Killing Chrome Extensions with 1 Week Publishing Delays

#2
I really hope this gets changed as this currently makes fixing small changes a massive, and wanting to release a feature at the same time on a website and extension means the chrome version must be done a week in advance. This is really killing productivity

Re: Google Killing Chrome Extensions with 1 Week Publishing Delays

#7

Given how much malware the Chrome Web Store pushes, and how sensitive of data extensions have access to, actually taking the time to properly review updates is absolutely warranted.

For a typo? Did you read the post?

If I update the text or change a typo they take a week to release the update. During this time I can't release another version of my app.

Re: Google Killing Chrome Extensions with 1 Week Publishing Delays

#8

A "5 line diff" is absolutely enough code to add something malicious.

Why does it take a week to accept/deny that...?

Note that they aren't actually DOING anything in this week.

The Polar extension is literally just sitting waiting for someone to approve it because I updated the images.

Re: Google Killing Chrome Extensions with 1 Week Publishing Delays

#9

Given how much malware the Chrome Web Store pushes, and how sensitive of data extensions have access to, actually taking the time to properly review updates is absolutely warranted.

For a typo? Did you read the post? If I update the text or change a typo they take a week to release the update. During this time I can't release another version of my app.

They don't know you only fixed a typo until they've had time to review it

Re: Google Killing Chrome Extensions with 1 Week Publishing Delays

#10
While you are, of course, welcome to call upon Google to improve the review speed, there are obvious things you can do on your side as well.

First up: improve the QA process on your extension to avoid having to do 5-line diffs every few days.

In the meantime, you can offer your users to switch to "developer mode" and install the extension manually.

I personally would be against the centralized nature of Chrome extensions world anyway (which, by definition, leads to bottlenecks, for dubious benefits), but at one point Google claimed there were 180,000+ extensions in the web store, and if only 0,1% of those get updated every week, that's 180 extensions to be reviewed every week.

Post reply on HN