Live data from Hacker News

Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

gitboxapp.com

11–20 of 73 posts

Re: Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

#11
post #10
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

First, it is not a browser. You actually do commits, merges and manipulate branches. The size is that big because Gitbox is bundled with official Git binaries so you don't have to install anything else. I will see how to bring the size down in the next versions. Anyway, this fact does not affect the performance and does not eat much memory.

so is that better than gitx?

Gitbox is better because it is a pleasure to use. There are tons of little details which matter in a daily work. For instance, when you switch a branch and try to commit to it, the branch name will be highlighted to remind you that the branch was switched since last commit. If you forgot to switch back, you just cancel the prompt. This little thing instantly eliminates 50% of use cases for "git reset --hard" or "git cherry pick" and makes you happier. Also, Gitbox fetches remote commits automatically so see that you have to pull something: this eliminates unnecessary merge commits.

Re: Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

#12
I've been trying hard to use GitBox for the last 2 month (beta version), but the lack of a quick view for commits makes me always revert back to GitX.

With GitX, I can easily cycle through all the files and see a quick summary of what was changed. With GitBox, I have to double click on every single file to get the diff. Either that, or just blind commit files. Not good options.

GitBox has the best push/pull functionality of any git client so far. But its crappy commit panel is really holds it back.

Re: Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

#13

I've been trying hard to use GitBox for the last 2 month (beta version), but the lack of a quick view for commits makes me always revert back to GitX. With GitX, I can easily cycle through all the files and see a quick summary of what was changed. With GitBox, I have to double click on every single file to get the diff. Either that, or just blind commit files. Not good options. GitBox has the best push/pull functiona…

All points a valid and will be addressed in the upcoming versions.

Re: Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

#15
post #14

The tagline seems quite negative: "Linus made Git for himself. Gitbox brings Git to everyone." Without Linus' free creation this app wouldn't exist at all.

It's not negative at all. It is a credit to Linus as a creator. Linus made a great tool and the command line UI is enough for him. Gitbox just makes his creation accessible to others and everybody wins.

Re: Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

#17
post #16

so, iam on ppc, will you provide 10.5 in the future?

Unfortunately, no. Gitbox is designed on top of GCD and blocks which are available in 10.6 (which is Intel-only). The tradeoff is worth it: with GCD I was able to implement sophisticated control flow cleaner and faster, and fix a lot of bugs.

Re: Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

#18

No Github integration, and does not seem to provide much over GitX. At the very least, GitX does have an inline diff viewer when you browse revisions. In Gitbox you have to click a modified file, and then it will launch FileMerge. Too uncomfortable.

Which fork of GitX would you recommend?

Maintaining a tool like this is basically unpleasant. You either need to be maintaining it for internal customers in a large company, or you need to sell it as a product - in other words, it's one of those products you really want to get paid for.

Maybe having a paid project will help keep this app actively developed.

Re: Gitbox 1.0 released: a version control app for Mac

#19
post #16

so, iam on ppc, will you provide 10.5 in the future?

Unfortunately, no. Gitbox is designed on top of GCD and blocks which are available in 10.6 (which is Intel-only). The tradeoff is worth it: with GCD I was able to implement sophisticated control flow cleaner and faster, and fix a lot of bugs.

i see =/ well, ppc is drifting slowly out. but iam looking forward to buy a intel mac in the future, hopefully your application is still maintained =)
Post reply on HN