Live data from Hacker News

I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

fastcompany.com

51–60 of 182 posts

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#51
Very good article. However, one point stands out:

> Despite everything that had happened with my mom and sister, I had made one of the most common mistakes; all of my social media accounts were public.

I've taken the opposite stance and preferred public accounts: that way I don't post anything I'm not comfortable with being seen by the world. IMHO the false sense of privacy setting would end up making me providing a lot more data to networks.

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#52
When I was a child my parents would consistently tell me that I should never put details about myself on the internet. But when Facebook became a thing it was suddenly okay to share pictures of your birthday party with complete strangers.

Personally, I don't feel comfortable with the idea of my photos being taken out of context and used in a way that I wouldn't agree with. Oddly enough, most of my friends don't see this as an issue.

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#53
post #7

My wife and I recently had our first child, and we decided we didn't want her to have any kind of social media presence until she was old enough to make that decision for herself. It's been a challenge ensuring friends and family don't post stuff about our daughter, but reading this reinforces that we're making the right choice.

What is "old enough"?

I would hope it would be closer to 16 yrs of age

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#55
I immediately thought of the discourse surrounding Sally Mann upon reading this. The intent is different, the medium different, but I don't think the questions around her work have been satisfactorily resolved. If anything, they're heightened by the ease with which non-famous artists can gain extensive audience.

"Can a child freely give consent to be photographed, especially in vulnerable positions including nudity, when the photographer is a parent? Do these photographs unintentionally put children at greater risk given the reality of pedophilia in society? Do they unintentionally encourage a sexualized view of childhood? Does such work on any level exploit these actual children?"

https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/text-idx?cc=mqr;c=mqr;...

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#56
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed, really impressive. It also impressed me to see what she's involved in at school: > Sonia Bokhari is an 8th grader and a persuasive and narrative writer. She is also the leader of her middle school’s Gay-Straight Alliance and a member of the school’s Environmental Club. She might not be the average 14yo :)

Yeah, she might be the parent-pressured 14yo.

wouldn't surprise me considering that she has the kind of parents that post online all the time about their kids

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#57
post #20

> When I saw the pictures that she had been posting on Facebook for years, I felt utterly embarrassed, and deeply betrayed. Well, that's because you're 13, the age when kids turn blase and embarrassed about being kids, and of the childish things they used to like. It's not like her mother did anything specially wrong, e.g. posting the letter to the tooth fairy, and so on. It's only embarrassing to her because she's 1…

I respectfully disagree. Children have a right to their own privacy from the rest of the world and it is a parents' responsibility to respect that. My son is only 11 months old but neither my wife, our family/friends, or myself post pictures of him or any intimate details on social media. They can be shared privately but not on social media.

Okay. Well then parents can go through and delete photos their kids want removed from Facebook.

If the parent's Facebook is private, that'll probably be the end of that.

Since I'm perfectly willing to do this for my child once they're old enough to form opinions about their own privacy, I don't see the problem with sharing photos of them to my private network while they aren't.

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#58
This really reinforces a small conversation I had on Mastodon last week about creating mastodon communities for families (ie a family has their own private mastodon instance). Now mom, dad, gramma, and even younger kids can participate in social media together but not in the public eye. Maybe allow white listing of other families' instances so gram can keep up with other families or other grandkids not in her instance or so parents can plan stuff.

Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc are too big and too open for kids (heck, I am a father of two and I don't feel comfortable on the platforms because they are too public).

Also, I have no desire to see my children use traditional social media, they are toxic and are breeding grounds for bullying.

Re: I’m 14, and I quit social media after discovering what was posted about me

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of the reasons I left Facebook was the amount of web presence people give their young children. It's not that I don't think children are adorable. I'm talking about parents who have a baby and then spend every day posting photos about every event in the child's life. I know 3 people in my relatively small circle who have been posting on behalf of their children for years . Maybe I'm a freak, but I think there's s…

I totally agree, I deactivated my Facebook a few years back. We use WhatsApp to share pictures and information about our baby with close friends and family, just hope the end-to-end encryption is legit. One big concern for me was the idea of Facebook having a 'shadow profile' of our daughter without our consent.

The point is, if you are sharing it with close family/friends, and their presence in the photo could prompt them to share it in their facebook. So in some way, it will end up in someone's profile with a tag to you/your kids name, unless you explicitly say every time "don't share".
Post reply on HN