Live data from Hacker News

Tandberg attempts to patent x264 open source algorithm

x264dev.multimedia.cx

41–46 of 46 posts

Re: Tandberg attempts to patent x264 open source algorithm

#41

"To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." - Article 1, Section 8, Clause 8 of the United States Constitution

This is a pandering quote which everyone already knows and not really a useful comment at all.

This is a frank response to a pandering quote which serves to let everybody know that you are a good comment watchdog and won't just ignore bullshit.

Re: Tandberg attempts to patent x264 open source algorithm

#42
Norwegian news site digi.no picked up this story and have a statement from Tandberg. Tandberg claims that their invention is different from what's in x264 and that they invented it before x264 the referred code.

Google translated link: http://translate.google.com/translate?js=n&prev=_t&h...

Re: Tandberg attempts to patent x264 open source algorithm

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I work for TANDBERG (now a part of Cisco) and I've dropped a note to Lars, the "inventor" in the patent. I certainly would like to hear the other side of the story and will share it if I get it.

What "other side" is there, if it's a step-by-step description of x264?

Well apparently one side is the mob

Re: Tandberg attempts to patent x264 open source algorithm

#45
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Eventually, copyright will die off completely. It's just a matter of when. When we have sci-fi nanoreplicators that can copy luxury (flying) cars, food, etc., all scarcity will be artificial. Alternatively, when we have very convincing VR, everyone will be able to experience what he or she wants to as much as he or she wants to. There won't be anything to trade because you can't give someone something they can't alre…

Intellectual property will become even more of a problem in a post scarcity society. Those that hold the IP will not want to give it up just because it's value is no longer in the physical creation. The music recording industry is effectively already becoming a post scarcity industry, and look how unwilling they are to give up their copyrights. Industries will cling on to things like rights to reproduce, rights to di…

I don't think an AI Justin Bieber is that far off.

AIs can create pop music in your virtual world if you like that sort of thing. All the other AIs will be talking about it, so you won't need some central source of anything in order to have common ground with people in your reality.

It will be fine if random permutations lead to people in your virtual reality listening to "Yeah, Girl" instead of "Girl, Yeah" or "All Right Girl".

Movies won't be very important when you can interactively experience anything you want. Climb K2 but without the risk of permanent death. Movies will just be a Machinima subset of the interactive simulation if you still want them.

Re: Tandberg attempts to patent x264 open source algorithm

#46
post #44

The norwegian link clearly states that they have documented their algorithm 7 months before it was released from x264. If this is true, there is definately nothing to see here...

They _claim_ to have documented it internally. Garrett-Glaser has publicly documented his case. Any blind faith in the accuracy of Tandberg's response is not shared by me.
Post reply on HN