Live data from Hacker News

Notepad++ drops code signing for its releases

notepad-plus-plus.org

331–335 of 335 posts

Re: Notepad++ drops code signing for its releases

#331

In case anyone reads this far down: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/da... Follow the steps under “Buy a DigiCert EV code signing certificate“. You’re welcome. ;)

I want to personally thank you for this. I cancelled my order with Comodo/SSLStore and followed your suggestion. EV certificate is already in the mail :)

Re: Notepad++ drops code signing for its releases

#332
post #70

Windows signing is a ripoff, $500/year you're getting nothing. Your certificate is not trusted. You have to "get reputation for it" before Windows Defender would stop giving users warnings. Also, renewing certificate is not a thing. Every time you have to get a new one, with same story of "reputation" again. [1] https://www.digicert.com/order/order-1.php

At least Windows lets you install pretty much whatever you want. None of this nonsense is mandatory.

Not from my experience. Many Windows users have anti-viruses installed, and they flag unsigned soft. I'm speaking from experience: it is cheaper to buy pricy certificate than loose big chunks of customers because of Windows Defender warnings. This is especially problem if you have software with rapid development cycle. Like I do - we got daily builds going up every couple days or so.

Also, Windows "trust system" seemingly works also on unsigned binaries. If you don't disable bunch of security settings, you would be blocked similar to self-signed certificates on HTTPS. You can go around, by clicking tiny button. Is enough users do it, software getting flagged as OK.

Certificate solves that this should be done per certificate, not per binary.

Re: Notepad++ drops code signing for its releases

#333
post #70

Windows signing is a ripoff, $500/year you're getting nothing. Your certificate is not trusted. You have to "get reputation for it" before Windows Defender would stop giving users warnings. Also, renewing certificate is not a thing. Every time you have to get a new one, with same story of "reputation" again. [1] https://www.digicert.com/order/order-1.php

> Also, renewing certificate is not a thing. Oh, no. We just kept renewing our EV certs with them for past several years... if only we'd known that we can't. Damn. Such an amateur shop this Digicert. Unacceptable.

You are getting new EV certificate every time.

Re: Notepad++ drops code signing for its releases

#334
post #70

Windows signing is a ripoff, $500/year you're getting nothing. Your certificate is not trusted. You have to "get reputation for it" before Windows Defender would stop giving users warnings. Also, renewing certificate is not a thing. Every time you have to get a new one, with same story of "reputation" again. [1] https://www.digicert.com/order/order-1.php

Wait are you saying that Apple Developer program for 99$/year is actually quite a good deal in comparison? I will definitely pull this thread out next time someone complain that Apple is too expensive and that they are milking the poor developers...

For macOS for 99/year you're getting nice green pass on Gatekeeper.

For 400$/ year you're getting nothing. I was told here that I could go lower, but this is what I was paying for last decade.

Re: Notepad++ drops code signing for its releases

#335
post #75
post #70

Windows signing is a ripoff, $500/year you're getting nothing. Your certificate is not trusted. You have to "get reputation for it" before Windows Defender would stop giving users warnings. Also, renewing certificate is not a thing. Every time you have to get a new one, with same story of "reputation" again. [1] https://www.digicert.com/order/order-1.php

There's a backdoor that lets your bypass the SmartScreen reputation requirement: pay more money for an EV cert[1]. I don't agree with this industry practice. Reputation requirements either shouldn't have backdoors or shouldn't exist in the first place. 1. https://twitter.com/JosephRyanRies/status/951643158118567937

I can not stick EV token into my cloud VPS build server.
Post reply on HN