Live data from Hacker News

Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

techcrunch.com

71–80 of 157 posts

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#71
At the risk of being downvoted, any Pixel users enable "Hey Google" recognition on their phones only to regret it?

I'm constantly dealing with the phone interpreting commands intended for a Google Home speaker, which sometimes results in both the speaker and the phone acting on the same command. To my dismay, there's no way to disable Hey Google recognition on the phone after it's been enabled.

Perhaps someone here has run into this issue as well? It's a huge pain point for me.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#72
post #67
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I get updates every 30 days. Do they expire if you don’t update?

Yes

That's stupid. I do offline maps mainly for the times when I don't have a good connection. It makes no sense to lose the maps when you are spending an extended amount of time off-grid. That's exactly when you need offline maps.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#73
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google Maps has an excellent offline mode on iOS and Android. I wish Apple Maps had that too.

It's one of those features that makes one think... Why am I being notified about this at all? Can't this be taken care of without my input?

I am being notified but the process starts automatically. No input needed.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#74
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Citation?

There is this new type of trolling where someone just puts in bare minimal counterarguments and asks for citations knowing full well it's labour intensive to do so. If your not trolling.. your not doing a good job of avoiding these comparisons. The onus should be on you here to provide citations first that dissprove the person your replying to.

I'm not trolling. The statement that RNN are somehow more noise-tolerant than CNNs does not make sense to me, and is not based on any literature about noise tolerance in NNs that I'm familiar with. Also, no arguments have been provided as to why this could possibly be the case.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#76
post #71

At the risk of being downvoted, any Pixel users enable "Hey Google" recognition on their phones only to regret it? I'm constantly dealing with the phone interpreting commands intended for a Google Home speaker, which sometimes results in both the speaker and the phone acting on the same command. To my dismay, there's no way to disable Hey Google recognition on the phone after it's been enabled. Perhaps someone here h…

You can register different trigger words, or at least you used to be able to. I had my phone wired to OK Google and the Home wired to Hey Google. Wasn’t an issue once I made the distinction. I no longer have an Android so I can’t comment on this still working. If you have external parties at your home regularly, that would obviously complicate things.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#77
post #2

"But it’s sort of funny considering hardly any of Google’s other products work offline. Are you going to dictate into a shared document while you’re offline? Write an email? Ask for a conversion between liters and cups? You’re going to need a connection for that!" While offline, you might write email drafts, your blog, or even a book: https://medium.com/@augustbirch/what-i-learned-writing-an-en... What's missing is t…

It means google doesn't need to pay for all the servers busy doing speech recognition. They shifted that work to the user's device.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#78
post #7

Call me cynical but I cannot picture Google not tapping into everything you run through their voice recognition software, even if it does work offline. Doesn't mean it won't phone home later.

For what? They only really make their money on ads for things you're actively searching for. Everything else they have in ads works rather poorly in the text world. Trying to interpret interests out of task-driven voice commands is way beyond their capabilities. But, enough of that. I'm holding out until decent voice dictation is standard everywhere and a well understood engineering problem with good open source impl…

You might be waiting a while. The problem you describe - with GPS - is an acoustic modeling problem, and a very difficult one at that. Cars come in many shapes and make lots of odd noises and various speeds, not to mention these devices are mounted in many places in relation to the speaker.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#79
post #75

Hmm, is this how the "what song is playing" feature works? Google claims it works offline (I haven't tested it) but I have a hard time believing that Google is storing information related to every song out there. What about new songs?

You never heard of Google Music? I believe getting fingerprints of all published music is probably one of the least complex tasks Google faces.

Re: Google’s new voice recognition system works instantly and offline (Pixel only)

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For what? They only really make their money on ads for things you're actively searching for. Everything else they have in ads works rather poorly in the text world. Trying to interpret interests out of task-driven voice commands is way beyond their capabilities. But, enough of that. I'm holding out until decent voice dictation is standard everywhere and a well understood engineering problem with good open source impl…

You might be waiting a while. The problem you describe - with GPS - is an acoustic modeling problem, and a very difficult one at that. Cars come in many shapes and make lots of odd noises and various speeds, not to mention these devices are mounted in many places in relation to the speaker.

The voice recognition on Android Auto works fine in the interior of every car where I've tried it. The manufacturers include well-placed microphones dedicated to the purpose.
Post reply on HN