Live data from Hacker News

Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page

google.com

21–30 of 54 posts

Re: Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page

#21
The official page for the extension has examples of the types of comments made using this tool: https://dissenter.com/

From Andrew Torba (CEO of Gab):

> Being that I'm barred from commenting on Hacker News, I'm going to comment using Dissenter. Lol @ the Silicon Valley dweebs already screaming "reeeee natttziii" on this post.

Re: Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page

#23

Not only there are multiple plugins that do this now, this is something that was explored by Google itself back in 2009 with Google Sidewiki[1]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Sidewiki

But how many of those solutions work as well as Dissenter? Do any of them hold a strong position on free speech?

Edit: I was genuinely asking because I had not heard of similar solutions prior to today. But go ahead and keep downvoting me. That'll teach me to engage in honest conversation.

Re: Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page

#25
post #7

Remember Pushnote[0], wasn't that basically the same thing? It's definitely an interesting concept and there's a market there but not when it's a 'Nazi' site backing it. [0] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/06/14/fry_pushnote_bye/

“Ad hominem is a notoriously weak logical argument. And is usually used to distract the focus of a discussion - to move it from an indefensible point and to attack the opponent." ~ Lord Aquitainus Attis

Nobody made a "logical argument", it's a fact or opinion.

Re: Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page

#26

The official page for the extension has examples of the types of comments made using this tool: https://dissenter.com/ From Andrew Torba (CEO of Gab): > Being that I'm barred from commenting on Hacker News, I'm going to comment using Dissenter. Lol @ the Silicon Valley dweebs already screaming "reeeee natttziii" on this post.

That's funny since Torba blocked me for posting information from Gab's own financial filings.

Re: Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“Ad hominem is a notoriously weak logical argument. And is usually used to distract the focus of a discussion - to move it from an indefensible point and to attack the opponent." ~ Lord Aquitainus Attis

It is entirely appropriate to attack literal self-claimed Nazis.

Libel much?

Re: Gab Launches Dissenter: Comment on Any Internet Page

#30

The official page for the extension has examples of the types of comments made using this tool: https://dissenter.com/ From Andrew Torba (CEO of Gab): > Being that I'm barred from commenting on Hacker News, I'm going to comment using Dissenter. Lol @ the Silicon Valley dweebs already screaming "reeeee natttziii" on this post.

So... it’s a mobile echo-chamber with delusions of trolling a web that isn’t even aware it’s being trolled, because they won’t sign up to see the trolling? That’s so... so weird, even by Gab standards.
Post reply on HN