Live data from Hacker News

SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

wsj.com

31–40 of 314 posts

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#31
post #23

At this point, the board of directors should just demand deletion of his Twitter account. I admire Elon for his vision, and actually also admire his radical style despite of its unpopular image - I watched the video where he smoked pot on the radio show. It was a really amazing conversation about future of humanity. He just needs to stop tweeting. You may say it’s fixing the symptom, but here if we take Twitter away,…

How about, "helped every piece of news break faster." I knew about every trade during the run up to today's 3pm NHL trade deadline many minutes and sometimes hours before the stories appeared on nhl.com or sportsnet, etc.

I enjoy reading about political news immediately but often times the breaking stories are wildly incorrect/off and I would benefit from more restrained and thoughtful coverage. Taking more time to make decisions rarely leads to bad decisions...

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#32
post #6

Can the SEC really do this given the content of this tweet? Surely they can’t seek approval for every tweet about Tesla? What if he says he’s driving home from “the Tesla factory”. Does this count as a breach if he didn’t seek approval?

Musk and his lawyers agreed to the terms of the settlement. The only reason he had to settle in the first place was because he tweeted false, market-moving information via twitter. Maybe Elon should have considered the consequences then. Why didn’t he just hand over his twitter password to a social media manager and stop tweeting once he lost millions of dollars over the last tweet?

Hubris.

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#35
post #6

Can the SEC really do this given the content of this tweet? Surely they can’t seek approval for every tweet about Tesla? What if he says he’s driving home from “the Tesla factory”. Does this count as a breach if he didn’t seek approval?

Musk and his lawyers agreed to the terms of the settlement. The only reason he had to settle in the first place was because he tweeted false, market-moving information via twitter. Maybe Elon should have considered the consequences then. Why didn’t he just hand over his twitter password to a social media manager and stop tweeting once he lost millions of dollars over the last tweet?

Clearly, he doesn't care that much.

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#36

At this point, the board of directors should just demand deletion of his Twitter account. I admire Elon for his vision, and actually also admire his radical style despite of its unpopular image - I watched the video where he smoked pot on the radio show. It was a really amazing conversation about future of humanity. He just needs to stop tweeting. You may say it’s fixing the symptom, but here if we take Twitter away,…

He doesn't need to delete it, but if he is going to post market moving information (like production for 2019 is not 400K but 500K) he'd get the approved by someone else like Tesla's GC.

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#37
post #26

This is where a software solution might actually help. As an example, I've added some keywords to a script in my IRC client that if they exist the message is stopped by my client. In Elon Musks' case this should be Tesla (and probably some other court mandated muzzles) and should be on their Twitter clients, and other "designated publication channels" that the ruling covers. Why? Because remembering to not do things…

you mean like the dozens of tools out there used by corporation's to approve and manage tweets that their social media teams send out.

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#38

At this point, the board of directors should just demand deletion of his Twitter account. I admire Elon for his vision, and actually also admire his radical style despite of its unpopular image - I watched the video where he smoked pot on the radio show. It was a really amazing conversation about future of humanity. He just needs to stop tweeting. You may say it’s fixing the symptom, but here if we take Twitter away,…

...Can a corporation demand an employee waive their right to speech as a private citizen? I think even if so, that's a terrible idea.

I mean, I'm fairly certain that if I started publicly bad-mouthing my company and they noticed, I'd be canned.

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#39

At this point, the board of directors should just demand deletion of his Twitter account. I admire Elon for his vision, and actually also admire his radical style despite of its unpopular image - I watched the video where he smoked pot on the radio show. It was a really amazing conversation about future of humanity. He just needs to stop tweeting. You may say it’s fixing the symptom, but here if we take Twitter away,…

He doesn't need to delete it, but if he is going to post market moving information (like production for 2019 is not 400K but 500K) he'd get the approved by someone else like Tesla's GC.

Incidentally Tesla's new GC has only been on the job for 5 days after the previous GC left two months into the job.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/20/tesla-replaces-general-couns...

Re: SEC Asks Manhattan Federal Court to Hold Elon Musk in Contempt

#40

At this point, the board of directors should just demand deletion of his Twitter account. I admire Elon for his vision, and actually also admire his radical style despite of its unpopular image - I watched the video where he smoked pot on the radio show. It was a really amazing conversation about future of humanity. He just needs to stop tweeting. You may say it’s fixing the symptom, but here if we take Twitter away,…

...Can a corporation demand an employee waive their right to speech as a private citizen? I think even if so, that's a terrible idea.

This is true for every employee of every public company on the planet. We're discussing it here because Mr. Musk thinks the rules don't apply to him.
Post reply on HN