Live data from Hacker News

AMA: Bill Gates

reddit.com

11–20 of 178 posts

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#11
post #2

Do people derive pleasure from these AMAs? Gates seems to reply with the same platitudes and non-answers to the point where its hard to tell if it’s him or the BMGF publicist.

What non-answers are you referring to? Most of the ones I read were responded with what the askers were wanting to know. They might get repetitive, but that's because people ask the same questions all the time.

He didn't really answer the billionaire happiness question.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#12
post #2

Do people derive pleasure from these AMAs? Gates seems to reply with the same platitudes and non-answers to the point where its hard to tell if it’s him or the BMGF publicist.

For me, not really. A live text interview is probably the worst medium for this type of content (exhibit A: Kara Swisher & Jack Dorsey). There is also a lot of subtly missed when comparing speech to text, and due to the time delay it gives the interviewee time to apply any relevant PR spin.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#13
post #9

I wonder, if Gates was still driving Windows development would Windows 10 still spy on users and restrict their ability to control updates like it does with Nadella at the helm?

Yes I remember Gates was a true Saint when he was running Microsoft.

I hate Windows10 like anyone with any self respect and appreciation to Privacy, and this is why I am still on a heavily fortified Win8.1 (with Classic Shell UI).

Microsoft is doing what Facebook is doing. You either 'shut up' and accept the T&C, or go your merry way and use Fedora and SMS.

They don't do it for the fun of it, they do it for the $$$ of it. And since both they got greedy shareholders to keep happy, there is only one way forward (for these/such companies).

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#14
post #2

Do people derive pleasure from these AMAs? Gates seems to reply with the same platitudes and non-answers to the point where its hard to tell if it’s him or the BMGF publicist.

I skimmed the AMA for a few minutes, and saw him say that:

- He thought nuclear weapons, bioterrorism, and climate change were the biggest threats to humanity.

- He thought paying $10B in capital gains taxes was not enough and he should have paid more.

Maybe those are platitudes but it's real enough for me.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#15
post #2

Do people derive pleasure from these AMAs? Gates seems to reply with the same platitudes and non-answers to the point where its hard to tell if it’s him or the BMGF publicist.

His answers seem quite concrete to me. He even links further reading after answering questions directly. I don't really see any platitudes or non-answers at all. Maybe it's predictable? But it seems his answers are genuine, to-the-point, and even provides the reader with further reading. Not sure what more you could ask for really. Edit: I mean, look at this answer: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/aunv58/im_bi…

In response to your edit: he said the same thing on The Verge [1] a week or two ago. I think maybe what the OP is getting at is that there's really nothing revealing or exclusive that comes out of these AMAs; it's just another media outlet.

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/12/18220756/bill-gates-tax-r...

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#16
post #2

Do people derive pleasure from these AMAs? Gates seems to reply with the same platitudes and non-answers to the point where its hard to tell if it’s him or the BMGF publicist.

You think the BGMF publicist decided to say Gates watches American Vandal and has a trampoline room in his house?

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#17
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes I remember Gates was a true Saint when he was running Microsoft.

I hate Windows10 like anyone with any self respect and appreciation to Privacy, and this is why I am still on a heavily fortified Win8.1 (with Classic Shell UI). Microsoft is doing what Facebook is doing. You either 'shut up' and accept the T&C, or go your merry way and use Fedora and SMS. They don't do it for the fun of it, they do it for the $$$ of it. And since both they got greedy shareholders to keep happy, ther…

Apologies for the follow-up, no spam intended.

For this AMA he self-identified as "co-chair of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation", and I have to admit that as a syst-admin 'some time ago', I made my living with Microsoft products.

And now as a 'wiser' (snicker) human being, I appreciate his efforts to improve Humanity via his dedication and actions.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His answers seem quite concrete to me. He even links further reading after answering questions directly. I don't really see any platitudes or non-answers at all. Maybe it's predictable? But it seems his answers are genuine, to-the-point, and even provides the reader with further reading. Not sure what more you could ask for really. Edit: I mean, look at this answer: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/aunv58/im_bi…

In response to your edit: he said the same thing on The Verge [1] a week or two ago. I think maybe what the OP is getting at is that there's really nothing revealing or exclusive that comes out of these AMAs; it's just another media outlet. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/12/18220756/bill-gates-tax-r...

I must be missing it, but I don't see the "same thing" at all. On reddit, he is a lot more human, providing a direct answer to the question and revealing personal information and opinions (like the $10BO) that doesn't seem to be written in that Verge article or elsewhere.

Seems super valuable and interesting to me to have Reddit AMAs, and I'm just not seeing this "platitudes" thing or "just another media outlet" attitude. Sure, he's on a talking tour or whatever, but he's on reddit answering real questions with real answers not seen elsewhere.

Seems interesting enough to me, and not at all like what OP is decrying here for being "platitudes"/"non-answers".

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#19
post #14
post #2

Do people derive pleasure from these AMAs? Gates seems to reply with the same platitudes and non-answers to the point where its hard to tell if it’s him or the BMGF publicist.

I skimmed the AMA for a few minutes, and saw him say that: - He thought nuclear weapons, bioterrorism, and climate change were the biggest threats to humanity. - He thought paying $10B in capital gains taxes was not enough and he should have paid more. Maybe those are platitudes but it's real enough for me.

in other words, war is dangerous and he pays too little tax. i think too they are platitudes.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#20
post #16
post #2

Do people derive pleasure from these AMAs? Gates seems to reply with the same platitudes and non-answers to the point where its hard to tell if it’s him or the BMGF publicist.

You think the BGMF publicist decided to say Gates watches American Vandal and has a trampoline room in his house?

Well, that explains his Mario-tier jumping skills: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TCxE0bWQeQ

He talked about the trampoline on the Ellen Show, so yes, it still counts as a PR-y answer.

Post reply on HN