Live data from Hacker News

What would happen if Facebook were turned off?

economist.com

51–56 of 56 posts

Re: What would happen if Facebook were turned off?

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed there is a difference. Not so much agreed that it meaningfully suppresses the echo chamber effect. The ultimate result is the same. That which sufficiently differs with the views of the majority of the people on this site tends to be seen less, or not at all depending on the extent of the disagreement. Except for us heretics with showdead enabled.

agreed. But the majority here define the "acceptable" opinions, not the individual. Also, I've had climate-skeptic comments upvoted and culture-war comments downvoted in contradiction to the dominant narrative here, so it does seem to be post-by-post rather than site-wide chambering.

> But the majority here define the "acceptable" opinions, not the individual.

That doesn't seem better to me. :( You are right that sometimes counter-hive-mind comments get upvoted, though, if written just the right way. I hope this happens more often in the future.

Re: What would happen if Facebook were turned off?

#52
The real problem with FB is addiction. People especially kids get a shot of dopamine for every "like" on social media. It is also an escape from reality and it is possible to carry on a fantasy life. This experience isn't going to end well.

Re: What would happen if Facebook were turned off?

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We shouldn't be the pot calling the kettle black. This place is an echo chamber on a variety of topics to the same extent or worse than I've ever seen on FB or Reddit.

I think the difference is that only individual posts get downvoted here. I (used to) have friends on FB who will unfriend anyone epxressing an opinion that they don't agree with (or "find offensive"). They end up in an echo chamber where they never hear an opinion they don't already agree with, and then get surprised when elections don't turn out the way they wanted. Weirdly, I'm still friends with some of them irl,…

>Unpopular opinions on HN get downvoted to invisibility

Do they? In my experience (admittedly limited, a couple of years) things get a lot of downvotes almost always for how they say it, not what they say. Can anyone give counterexamples? A well-expressed comment worth reading but downvoted to invisibility?

Re: What would happen if Facebook were turned off?

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the difference is that only individual posts get downvoted here. I (used to) have friends on FB who will unfriend anyone epxressing an opinion that they don't agree with (or "find offensive"). They end up in an echo chamber where they never hear an opinion they don't already agree with, and then get surprised when elections don't turn out the way they wanted. Weirdly, I'm still friends with some of them irl,…

>Unpopular opinions on HN get downvoted to invisibility Do they? In my experience (admittedly limited, a couple of years) things get a lot of downvotes almost always for how they say it, not what they say. Can anyone give counterexamples? A well-expressed comment worth reading but downvoted to invisibility?

I have no idea if there's a perceived difference in how I'm saying things, but I definitely notice that the unpopular opinions I hold get downvoted to invisibility.

Re: What would happen if Facebook were turned off?

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Unpopular opinions on HN get downvoted to invisibility Do they? In my experience (admittedly limited, a couple of years) things get a lot of downvotes almost always for how they say it, not what they say. Can anyone give counterexamples? A well-expressed comment worth reading but downvoted to invisibility?

I have no idea if there's a perceived difference in how I'm saying things, but I definitely notice that the unpopular opinions I hold get downvoted to invisibility.

Do you have some examples of that? Links? I should do an Ask about it I guess.. Examples seem hard to come by.

Re: What would happen if Facebook were turned off?

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no idea if there's a perceived difference in how I'm saying things, but I definitely notice that the unpopular opinions I hold get downvoted to invisibility.

Do you have some examples of that? Links? I should do an Ask about it I guess.. Examples seem hard to come by.

check my comment history and see the numerous downvoted comments ;)
Post reply on HN