Live data from Hacker News

How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

quantamagazine.org

11–20 of 24 posts

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#12
I actually think it's much simpler than all of this. I may be extrapolating from my own brain a bit, I'm fairly certain that the brain creates a timeline of the past by running a garbage collection function every night that goes something like:

    if (memory.timestamp 

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#13
post #12

I actually think it's much simpler than all of this. I may be extrapolating from my own brain a bit, I'm fairly certain that the brain creates a timeline of the past by running a garbage collection function every night that goes something like: if (memory.timestamp

I think its a bit more complex than that, maybe something like

  if (memory.timestamp  {
      memory.significance = score;
    })
  }

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#14
As a programmer I think I forget a lot because programming keeps my brain busy thinking about things. I forget features and solutions I've done before. I think it's because the space inside the brain is limited. I'm thinking hard about a new problem every day. Whereas my boss can remember things I did a year ago I can't easily.

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#15

As a programmer I think I forget a lot because programming keeps my brain busy thinking about things. I forget features and solutions I've done before. I think it's because the space inside the brain is limited. I'm thinking hard about a new problem every day. Whereas my boss can remember things I did a year ago I can't easily.

Maybe its just you being in the business longer than me, but I've had pretty much the opposite thought: I'm learning new stuff every day, wondering when I will start to actually forget chunks of it. Currently, it seems like most technical knowledge tends to stick in my brain, with no apparent limit yet. I can still recall most of the Redis protocol commands despite not having used it in more than six years.

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#16
post #15

As a programmer I think I forget a lot because programming keeps my brain busy thinking about things. I forget features and solutions I've done before. I think it's because the space inside the brain is limited. I'm thinking hard about a new problem every day. Whereas my boss can remember things I did a year ago I can't easily.

Maybe its just you being in the business longer than me, but I've had pretty much the opposite thought: I'm learning new stuff every day, wondering when I will start to actually forget chunks of it. Currently, it seems like most technical knowledge tends to stick in my brain, with no apparent limit yet. I can still recall most of the Redis protocol commands despite not having used it in more than six years.

After almost 20 years as a commercial developer I forget entire projects, entire jobs even. Someone will mention a company name and it takes me a few seconds to realize that the reason the name is familiar is because I briefly worked there 15 years ago. Jobs I held for multiple years are fine but any short stints are a blur.

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#17
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe its just you being in the business longer than me, but I've had pretty much the opposite thought: I'm learning new stuff every day, wondering when I will start to actually forget chunks of it. Currently, it seems like most technical knowledge tends to stick in my brain, with no apparent limit yet. I can still recall most of the Redis protocol commands despite not having used it in more than six years.

After almost 20 years as a commercial developer I forget entire projects, entire jobs even. Someone will mention a company name and it takes me a few seconds to realize that the reason the name is familiar is because I briefly worked there 15 years ago. Jobs I held for multiple years are fine but any short stints are a blur.

I've experienced this as well and the phenomenon is more pronounced if the role/company was unremarkable at the time, and it was as if I overwrote the memory with the excitement of the next job, then rinse and repeat with every new job.

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#18

As a programmer I think I forget a lot because programming keeps my brain busy thinking about things. I forget features and solutions I've done before. I think it's because the space inside the brain is limited. I'm thinking hard about a new problem every day. Whereas my boss can remember things I did a year ago I can't easily.

I find that my brain seems to be very selective about what it copies from "cache" into long-term memory. I think this is the result of decades of splitting my time between two 'modes' of thinking - one where I try to permanently commit some important fact to memory (like how a system works, or what functions it needs, or whatever), and the other where I'm churning through hundreds of pages of documentation trying to find the one particular fact that I need, where everything apart from that fact gets explicitly forgotten as soon as possible to make space for stuff that I actually need to keep.

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#19
post #13
post #12

I actually think it's much simpler than all of this. I may be extrapolating from my own brain a bit, I'm fairly certain that the brain creates a timeline of the past by running a garbage collection function every night that goes something like: if (memory.timestamp

I think its a bit more complex than that, maybe something like if (memory.timestamp { memory.significance = score; }) }

So if I understand correctly, you are suggesting that the dream playback is used as a way to determine the significance of a memory?

Re: How the Brain Creates a Timeline of the Past

#20
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe its just you being in the business longer than me, but I've had pretty much the opposite thought: I'm learning new stuff every day, wondering when I will start to actually forget chunks of it. Currently, it seems like most technical knowledge tends to stick in my brain, with no apparent limit yet. I can still recall most of the Redis protocol commands despite not having used it in more than six years.

After almost 20 years as a commercial developer I forget entire projects, entire jobs even. Someone will mention a company name and it takes me a few seconds to realize that the reason the name is familiar is because I briefly worked there 15 years ago. Jobs I held for multiple years are fine but any short stints are a blur.

I suspected that would probably happen someday (I'm 24). Do you notice this effect with your private life too? Forgotten relationships, appartments, vacations, etc?
Post reply on HN