Live data from Hacker News

Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 40 posts

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#11
post #3

Ask PG: What should I have for lunch? PG seems to have become a gnomic magic 8 ball of sorts. I can only hope for his sake that he's built Eliza-like behavior into HN such that his responses to all "Ask PG" questions are fully automated.

Breaking news! Paul Graham ate breakfast.

http://reddit.com/info/4jxe/comments

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#12
post #9

I think if Jerry and Filo had a chance to run the company for a while, they could probably surprise people. They're probably as smart as Larry and Sergey, but they've never had a chance to run Yahoo the way they'd like. If they had, it would have more of a hacker culture, and Google wouldn't be trampling them so badly.

Do you stay in touch with them, and/or with Yahoo in general?

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#13
post #5

Only two things would've caused them to spurn Microsoft—excessive self-worth or hubris—both of which are bad.

I'm not sure that I agree here. Despite the public statements to the contrary, I suspect that Yang's motivations are not about the short-term financial plan, but about the long-term survival of the company and of their culture. Microsoft is a massive organization, and has had several problems integrating smaller players into it's corporate structure. My suspicion is that a number of higher-level Yahoo members are con…

i totally agree with you - also if you're trying to get my baby (for whatever reason and price) then I would certainly make sure that my baby grows healthy, but the history says that chances of growing healthy with microsoft is very rare. Yang would also make sure that people (shareholders, employee and end-users) who love my baby so much today, keeps loving in the future as well - but it looked like only one person was loving the deal and other two (employees and end-users) were certainly not that happy with the deal so....

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#15
post #10
post #3

Ask PG: What should I have for lunch? PG seems to have become a gnomic magic 8 ball of sorts. I can only hope for his sake that he's built Eliza-like behavior into HN such that his responses to all "Ask PG" questions are fully automated.

A glass of prune juice or a nice marshmallow salad.

When we were going to say hi to you on the pre-Startup School dinner, we were joking that we should corner you and ask ALL the questions we have, existential or otherwise ("why am I here", "what is the meaning of life", "what is the best color" etc) :-)

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#16
post #3

Ask PG: What should I have for lunch? PG seems to have become a gnomic magic 8 ball of sorts. I can only hope for his sake that he's built Eliza-like behavior into HN such that his responses to all "Ask PG" questions are fully automated.

It would be hilarious if all Ask PGs just got the reply "make something people want."

Come on, he wouldn't just hard-code his mini-me!

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#17
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A glass of prune juice or a nice marshmallow salad.

When we were going to say hi to you on the pre-Startup School dinner, we were joking that we should corner you and ask ALL the questions we have, existential or otherwise ("why am I here", "what is the meaning of life", "what is the best color" etc) :-)

we invited you; it's a mistaken metaphor; ff6600

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#18
post #9

I think if Jerry and Filo had a chance to run the company for a while, they could probably surprise people. They're probably as smart as Larry and Sergey, but they've never had a chance to run Yahoo the way they'd like. If they had, it would have more of a hacker culture, and Google wouldn't be trampling them so badly.

Do you stay in touch with them, and/or with Yahoo in general?

Not really. And that was 10 years ago. Most of the people I know at Yahoo now started after I left.

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#19
post #10
post #3

Ask PG: What should I have for lunch? PG seems to have become a gnomic magic 8 ball of sorts. I can only hope for his sake that he's built Eliza-like behavior into HN such that his responses to all "Ask PG" questions are fully automated.

A glass of prune juice or a nice marshmallow salad.

BTW, http://members.wizzards.net/~mlworden/atyp/auden.htm

Re: Ask PG: What's your take on the Yahoo! situation?

#20

Slightly offtopic: this thread showed up as dead earlier today. Was it resurrected?

You must be new here. Links on the site fall off the stack eventually--but when you reload the page, new ones are made. It's a "feature" of the architecture pg used to build the site (continuations based).

So, if you sit idle on any of the comment pages for more than a few minutes it becomes unavailable. You have to start over on the main page and dig your way back down. I imagine this is not a fundamental flaw of a continuations-based design, since Seaside seems to cope with it OK (I guess?)...merely something that pg, or someone else, has not added the code to handle yet.

Post reply on HN