Live data from Hacker News

The Case for Transmissible Alzheimer's Grows

blogs.scientificamerican.com

21–30 of 133 posts

Re: The Case for Transmissible Alzheimer's Grows

#22

Dumb question (Wikipedia was of no help), if amyloid beta looks and acts like a prion, why isn't it classified as a prion?

It does seem like Abeta and prions should be in the same class.

A possible practical reason to keep them separated would be to avoid having various safety committees at X research institution from adding dozens of barriers to already difficult Alzheimer's research. Doing work with prions is a little like doing B. anthracis (Anthrax) research in some places - having to deal with indestructible spores.

Not that those safety measures shouldn't be put in place, but it'd make Alzheimer's/Abeta research slower and more expensive. The jump from BSL-1 to BSL2+/BSL-3 is huge [0].

[0] https://blink.ucsd.edu/safety/research-lab/biosafety/contain...

Re: The Case for Transmissible Alzheimer's Grows

#23
post #21
post #20

Great. Another reason to regret my lasik.

What other reasons do you have?

Dreading needing reading glasses. Night vision subjectively feels worse. Random yellow spots in changing light conditions that I don’t remember having before.

Re: The Case for Transmissible Alzheimer's Grows

#24

Does this line of inquiry mesh at all with the idea that "Gum disease–causing bacteria could spur Alzheimer’s" Or are they competing hypotheses? reported here in January: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18987015

My wife‘s grandmother had all her teeth pulled and replaced with implants (probably a hint towards lifelong gum issues, and PERHAPS stirring/aggravating infections), and 2 years later developed aggressive Alzheimer’s, dying about 3 years later. She was only 64 when she died. To my knowledge, she never had any neuro or eye surgery. It’s just n=1 of course, but to me the gum disease hypothesis looks way more promising.

Re: The Case for Transmissible Alzheimer's Grows

#27
post #25

So better skip eye exams?

What eye exam(s) involve physical contact between the eyeball and a medical instrument? Or did a joke just go sailing over my head?

Checking eye pressure involves an instrument touching the eye, and is pretty routine.

Re: The Case for Transmissible Alzheimer's Grows

#29
post #27
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What eye exam(s) involve physical contact between the eyeball and a medical instrument? Or did a joke just go sailing over my head?

Checking eye pressure involves an instrument touching the eye, and is pretty routine.

My guy uses a machine that does a puff of air. I've never had my eyeball physically touched by anything at an ophthalmologists office.

Re: The Case for Transmissible Alzheimer's Grows

#30
post #3

If prions stick to surgical instruments “like glue” what about needles and lancets? Could this be the link between diabetes and Alzheimer’s?

Those are all one time use though, right?

Apparently lots of diabetics reuse lancets (thread on another HN story a day or two ago). But I can't imagine anyone sharing used lancets (or needles... except for desperate addicts).
Post reply on HN