Live data from Hacker News

JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

theguardian.com

31–40 of 48 posts

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#31

This gives me the same feeling as all these old Prince recordings from his vault coming out. On one hand it feels wrong on the part of the family/rights owners to release this stuff against the wishes of the deceased, but on the other hand I really want that forbidden media.

Contrast Prince with Terry Pratchett, whose estate followed his wishes of destroying the hard drives containing Terry's unfinished works with a steamroller.[0] [0] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/aug/30/terry-pratchet...

That's terrible (to me, as a selfish fan).

I'm happy that Max Brod published Kafka's works against his will that they should be incinerated.

One never knows.

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#32
post #21

I recall reading some of his unpublished writings after they were leaked on what.cd, and I'm sure if you dig around some you'd be able to find mirrors somewhere on the web. Included in the leak was "The Ocean Full of Bowling Balls", the supposed prequel to "Catcher in the Rye". The leaker claimed something like a 6TB(!) bounty for leaking it too.

WCD was in a way Library of Alexandria of the private tracker world. It was just too good and didn't last forever like any other good thing. The only sad part is that nothing, of similar calibre, came after that. Btw couldn't find the leak anywhere though - searched by his name.

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#33
post #26
post #21

I recall reading some of his unpublished writings after they were leaked on what.cd, and I'm sure if you dig around some you'd be able to find mirrors somewhere on the web. Included in the leak was "The Ocean Full of Bowling Balls", the supposed prequel to "Catcher in the Rye". The leaker claimed something like a 6TB(!) bounty for leaking it too.

The discussion in that request thread about how to get the novel out of the reading room where one of the most entertaining ones I’ve read. I wish there was a backup. People were going crazy with coming up with plans and spy grade equipment to take pictures. Good times.

There's a backup of the torrents somewhere. Couple of months ago an ex admin had released it. Like backup of the catalogue but not the items.

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#34
post #8

Some will argue that it goes against everything Salinger would want. e.g. He doesn't want to be "judged" à la "Catcher in the Rye". However, if he truly never wanted them to be read, he would have burned them immediately after being written.

Why not take that to its logical conclusion and claim: if he truly never wanted them to be read, he would never have written them in the first place? To me it seems credible that a writer might want to hold on to some drafts, hoping to get round to editing them for publication, but doesn't want them edited by anyone else or published unedited. The question is, how to achieve that, seeing as one can't trust one's heir…

Writers don’t only write to be read.

Maybe he wrote them as practice. Maybe he wrote them to experiment with a new style. Maybe he wrote them to explore his thoughts and feelings. Who knows.

It does appear that he was okay with these things being published, but in the general case it’s not true that someone writing means they want or intend it to be published or even read.

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

An "evil genie" type can find all kinds of loopholes in a wish. I'd disassemble the building, move the pieces of it inside a larger museum with better public access, and affix the old walls to "structural remediation", which is to say that the pieces of the old building would be held up with steel beams and cables instead of each other. The "storage facility" for the other 90% of the collection would--entirely coinci…

Wholeheartedly agree. Once you're dead, you're dead. One's last wishes should definitely be respected to the first degree. That is, whomever you will your money, possessions, or property to should get those things. There should not be any strings attached beyond that, to the extent that a living person could not tie those same strings (or choose later to untie them)

What if I do not want to leave my money to anyone, or part of it?

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#36
post #21

I recall reading some of his unpublished writings after they were leaked on what.cd, and I'm sure if you dig around some you'd be able to find mirrors somewhere on the web. Included in the leak was "The Ocean Full of Bowling Balls", the supposed prequel to "Catcher in the Rye". The leaker claimed something like a 6TB(!) bounty for leaking it too.

It's the one place on the net I genuinely miss.

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wholeheartedly agree. Once you're dead, you're dead. One's last wishes should definitely be respected to the first degree. That is, whomever you will your money, possessions, or property to should get those things. There should not be any strings attached beyond that, to the extent that a living person could not tie those same strings (or choose later to untie them)

What if I do not want to leave my money to anyone, or part of it?

I’m not a lawyer, so I’m not sure. I imagine it would go to the state? Or you could specify the most extravagant funeral ever and be laid to rest in a diamond-encrusted gold coffin.

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#38
post #25

I remember that huge bounty for them on What.cd (RIP) with various discussions about how to go about getting a copy out of the Princeton library. Good times. I think the request might've ended up banned to attempt to avoid attracting more attention to the site after Microsoft COFEE[0] was actually uploaded there. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Online_Forensic_Evide...

Yes, those are the only two things I recall being taken down off what.cd for being too hot.

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#39
post #21

I recall reading some of his unpublished writings after they were leaked on what.cd, and I'm sure if you dig around some you'd be able to find mirrors somewhere on the web. Included in the leak was "The Ocean Full of Bowling Balls", the supposed prequel to "Catcher in the Rye". The leaker claimed something like a 6TB(!) bounty for leaking it too.

It's the one place on the net I genuinely miss.

What a sad day for the internet. There is a place seeking to fill its shoes if you know where to look...

Re: JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms

#40
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The discussion in that request thread about how to get the novel out of the reading room where one of the most entertaining ones I’ve read. I wish there was a backup. People were going crazy with coming up with plans and spy grade equipment to take pictures. Good times.

There's a backup of the torrents somewhere. Couple of months ago an ex admin had released it. Like backup of the catalogue but not the items.

I was talking about the request thread itself. Forum posts, requests are not included in the dump.
Post reply on HN