Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

theatlantic.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

61–70 of 78 posts

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#61

Post by bashwizard »

cal5k wrote: post #33
endorphone wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are very effective cold weather jackets, and have been designed and made for practical usage. High end outerwear is expensive across all brands. That it oddly took off as a fashion statement doesn't diminish the utility. Though I do think they are hitting the peak exposure moment, and soon they're going to have to remove the outer branding to allow utility buyers to not look like fashionistas.

This. Living in Toronto means living in a sea of Canada Goose wearers come winter. They're very well-made and warm coats - honestly far too warm for typical Toronto temperatures - but I wouldn't buy one currently because of the overt branding.

I don't like the overt branding either so I just got a black labeled one instead.

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#62

Post by ghaff »

paulcole wrote: post #46
elcomet wrote: post #4

Are Canada Goose coats really worth it in the first place ? I don't own one, but it seems to me that they are very expensive due to marketing and being trendy, but that you could get the same quality or better for much less.

For many people, fashion is a hobby and people like spending money on their hobbies. I’ve spent a lot of money on jackets and coats when a “better” one could’ve been bought for much less. Do I regret it? No. I feel good when I wear it and I like reading about clothes, trying things on, and deciding what to buy.

I'm willing to bet that at least some of the people all indignant about people buying coats that cost more than was "necessary" think very little about buying computers and other electronics that are more expensive than what they really need.

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#64

Post by scottlocklin »

joshlemer wrote: post #23
ghaff wrote: post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Much less"? Not so sure. Good winter coats aren't cheap even when there isn't obvious branding. In any case, most clothing has both fashion and utilitarian aspects. A friend of mine bought a coat from what is probably Canada Goose's main competitor in their Montreal factory store. It was expensive, even on sale, but it was also a very nice cold weather coat that fit well--in addition to looking good.

Which competitor is that?

Eddie Bauer, Patagonia, LL Bean, REI all make down jackets which are arguably just as good and are half to a quarter the price.

I always thought down was groace and sweaty myself. Even in super cold weather. Easier to adjust things using layers.

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#65

Post by slothtrop »

dsfyu404ed wrote: post #53
slothtrop wrote: post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's funny. If the label doesn't matter, why not opt for a less expensive option?

Same reason some (not all!) rich people take some of the badges off their very high end cars. Everyone knows you're driving a Mercedes sedan. No need to be a show off and let everyone know you bought the highest trim AMG, that would be impolite.

You say this in a thread literally about a counterfeit coat. People don't have access to Mercedes-Benz knock-offs.

> No need to be a show off and let everyone know you bought the highest trim AMG, that would be impolite.

I'd hazard with luxury vehicles, showing off is part of the appeal.

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#66

Post by phoobahr »

appleiigs wrote: post #36
elcomet wrote: post #4

Are Canada Goose coats really worth it in the first place ? I don't own one, but it seems to me that they are very expensive due to marketing and being trendy, but that you could get the same quality or better for much less.

I live in Alberta, Canada. Canada Goose is a fashion statement. The people who need a parka that warm will buy a cheaper parka that is just as warm. These people are outside working, getting dirty. You don’t need a Canada Goose in the city. You are just going from warm car to warm building. Best to wear layers when jumping from in and out. Same goes for winter activities.

I live in Canada, a cold part even. I live in a city, it's still cold. I haven't bought anything from Canada Goose but have spent similar money on layered clothing for similar (or better) performance.

Why?

Because I don't drive. I don't live with a driver. There's a very large assumption in your comment; the kind that an Alberta shouldn't make because ending up in a ditch for an hour could kill you.

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#67

Post by NeedMoreTea »

slothtrop wrote: post #65
dsfyu404ed wrote: post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same reason some (not all!) rich people take some of the badges off their very high end cars. Everyone knows you're driving a Mercedes sedan. No need to be a show off and let everyone know you bought the highest trim AMG, that would be impolite.

You say this in a thread literally about a counterfeit coat. People don't have access to Mercedes-Benz knock-offs. > No need to be a show off and let everyone know you bought the highest trim AMG, that would be impolite. I'd hazard with luxury vehicles, showing off is part of the appeal.

Higher end Mercs and BMWs have had a "dechrome" in the options list for years. That's paying for removing all model badges.

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#68

Post by hoaw »

Traster wrote: post #42

Here's a pro-tip for the apparently uninformed journalist: When you spent $1000 dollar on a fake coat and realized you were being conned the correct thing to do was NOT to go back to the same retailer to buy your next coat! I mean, really? If that's how you behave there's only so much sympathy you deserve.

Yes, really. It is essentially downside protection. If you find yourself in a uncertain situation, it is a reasonable strategy. She now already know that Amazon can handle a refund, what to look for when buying and got a recommendation from a friend for a jacket. Could she have walked into a physical store instead? Probably, but at this point she probably didn't want to buy an expensive jacket anymore which is also reasonable. You are the one not thinking.

I'll give you a different example. Say you are in a foreign city and you use Uber. After a while you have a bad experience. Say, the driver insists you pay something which should have beem included. You contact Uber and you get a refund. So what is the resonable choice now? A. Stay with Uber and be mindful of paying extra fees. B. Take other taxis which might be better, or just scam you without any recourse. For most people it would be A. Large brands win when the market is dysfunctional.

Re: I Spent $925 on a Fake Canada Goose Coat

#69

Post by goldcd »

NeedMoreTea wrote: post #18
elcomet wrote: post #4

Are Canada Goose coats really worth it in the first place ? I don't own one, but it seems to me that they are very expensive due to marketing and being trendy, but that you could get the same quality or better for much less.

I have a North Face down parka, with all sorts of implications it solves the same problem, that's simply not warm enough for me. It's even named McMurdo after the Antarctic research station, and cost about £350. There isn't too much out there with extreme rating, so if the likes of North Face and similar brands aren't warm enough you start to consider them regardless of price. Even if they have become surprisingly tr…

I've got the same one. Not had an issue with the warmth - but bulk is ridiculous (although I quite like it). Try pulling in the waist cords, it's a bit flappy and open otherwise.
Post reply on HN