Live data from Hacker News

Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

techcrunch.com

51–60 of 219 posts

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#51
post #13

I will be really interested to see this, because as it stands Facebook's messaging interface is barely any better than 2001's Hotmail (you do get a pretty picture with address autocomplete though). Going from where they are now to anywhere close to being a 'Gmail killer' is a humongous step.

I heard that Zuckerberg locked Paul Buchheit in a closet and told him he couldn't come out until he cloned Gmail.

It's being put into 'The Social Network 2: Return of the Lawsuits' as I write.

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#52
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The interface'll have the be unbelievably amazing and innovative for this to even make a dent in people's minds I guarantee you that they are going to become the default address between people 16 and under. My brother is 16 and doesn't have an email address, but he does have a facebook account.

... where 16 and under would mean 13-16. Facebook accounts aren't technically available to minors (under 13 years old).

My friends' baby boy had one at about 2 weeks old.

I know, the horror, the horror etc.

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#54
post #24
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Techcrunch? What are you talking about?

The title of their article.

"killer" is journalistic shorthand for "rival", they just want the conflict and the attendant pageviews, they don't care who wins or who is likely to win.

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#55

The interface'll have the be unbelievably amazing and innovative for this to even make a dent in people's minds. And as others have pointed out, Facebook.com is not associated with professionalism (unless you're a recruiter or tech blogger or something). All in all, I think nobody will care at the end of the day.

> The interface'll have the be unbelievably amazing and innovative for this to even make a dent in people's minds I guarantee you that they are going to become the default address between people 16 and under. My brother is 16 and doesn't have an email address, but he does have a facebook account.

Is that even possible? Can you sign up to Facebook without having an email address?

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#56
post #53

Does anyone have any decent info on which free mail service is the most popular? I know a fair amount of people use any mixture of hotmail, gmail and yahoo. Perhaps 'killing gmail' isn't as big as killing hotmail/live/badabingmail.

I'd be very interested to see stats on this, but my money is on yahoo. Despite their decline in the US and Europe, they are massively dominant in Asia in search, shopping and mail.

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#57

The interface'll have the be unbelievably amazing and innovative for this to even make a dent in people's minds. And as others have pointed out, Facebook.com is not associated with professionalism (unless you're a recruiter or tech blogger or something). All in all, I think nobody will care at the end of the day.

Despite my occasional pleas, it's already the messaging service of choice between my friends and friends-of-friends. They say it's easier to add people to a discussion, and it's hard to fight the momentum.

Except last I checked you couldn't include people in existing threads.

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#58
post #49
post #32

I've always thought that Facebook could make a real difference by becoming a central hub to control your "persona" or identity so to speak. Facebook could integrate with every other service and app under the sun, and users would not require to input information (any more then their Facebook uri) to register for anything. Instead they're trying to undercut Google by keeping them out of the 'shared data' agreement and…

> Facebook could integrate with every other service and app under the sun, and users would not require to input information (any more then their Facebook uri) to register for anything. Facebook has done exactly this, and there's been quite a bit of backlash, with some discussion on this site itself.

Facebook Connect has a long way from being the "identity manager" I speak of, and it's integration with applications as it is now leaves a lot to be desired. There has been backslash because 1) it's a mediocre implementation and 2) the lack of openness on behalf of Facebook and their methods are not in the best interest of either the users or the applications that could use this system.

Facebook could have become the central hub in which you can manage your identity (in an open way of course). Facebook could allow you to easily do anything on the web with fewer clicks by means of integration with other sevices. Instead they rather have you locked in to using their services and implementations and that is what I don't agree on. I wished it followed what I want, but whatever they do I wish it was adding value to the experience instead of just creating a more locked in ecosystem.

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#59
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The interface'll have the be unbelievably amazing and innovative for this to even make a dent in people's minds I guarantee you that they are going to become the default address between people 16 and under. My brother is 16 and doesn't have an email address, but he does have a facebook account.

That's the scariest thing I've read so far today.

1: My daughter just moved into her own house today. 2: Wow, awesome! I should call them to congratulate her! Whats the new house number? 1: Oh, she doesn't have a landline, she just uses her cell phone. 2: That's the scariest thing I've heard so far today. 1: ???...

To the newest generations email is an antiquated technology that has no real use among their peers. Eventually they might get some email address for college/professional use, but that's practically akin to a fresh college grad now getting a fax machine because "its what we use at the office".

Not shocking.

Edit: Unless by "the scariest thing" you mean the idea of xyz@facebook.com becoming the default for the >17 crowd, in which case, disregard my nonsense.

Re: Facebook’s Gmail Killer, Project Titan, Is Coming On Monday

#60
post #28

If @facebook.com email addresses have a stronger link to real, non-spammy, non-mass-produced identities than other domains, they could become preferred at many other sites -- a broader version of Facebook Connect.

Wrong -- your FB email address will likely have the same prefix as your vanity URL. Guess that that means? Spam bots know your email address already.

But Gmail has a good spam filter. So, you could use Gmail's POP features to connect to and download your Facebook emails.
Post reply on HN